Assorted retorts from yahoo boards and elsewhere
co-authors are other participants quoted. I haven't changed content of thr replies, but quoted it part by part in my replies, interspersing each reply after relevant part. Sometimes I have also changed the order of replies with my retorts, so as to prioritate logical/topical over temporal/chronological connexions. That has also involved conflating more than one message. I have also left out mere insults.
Pages
- Home
- Other blogs, same writer
- A thread from Catholic.com (more may be added)
- Answering Steve Rudd
- Have these dialogues taken place? Yes.
- Copyright issues on blogposts with shared copyright
- I think I wrote a mistaken word somewhere on youtube - or perhaps not
- What is Expertise? Some Things It is Not.
- It Seems Apocalypse is Explained in a Very Relevant Part
- Dialoguing Mainly with Adversaries
- Why do my Posts Right Here Not Answer YOUR Questio...
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Joomi Kim Made Some Points
Why does Christianity make us so uncomfortable these days?
Joomi Kim | 28 Sept. 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CI_LIg7beOc
The final distance from "post-war consensus" against religion and national loyalty ...
Gold. Thank you. When I learned German cultural history as part of 1 term full time = 2 terms half time German language and literature, I was of course rejecting Communism, in the Russian Zone.
But one thing that shocked me was Amerika-Häuser. Americans in the American zone were showing German women (and men) women wearing skirts that didn't cover the knees and things, and some German ladies were grossed out. That was the idea, gutting out the morality and religiosity in Germany.
Perhaps a bit like what Obama, Hillary Clinton, Kamala Harris have been pushing since 2008, but that was obviously even stronger.
4:52 How do you kill and torture a heretic?
Wouldn't it be easier to torture him first and then kill him?
More seriously, Inquisitors used less torture than secular courts and apart from Judaisers in Spain in c. 1600, the ones killed were far fewer than the ones given absolution and a penance, in Spain (including for witchcraft) that often being the Camino de Santiago.
5:11 "and initially the church was supportive of the heliocentric model of the universe which said that the earth revolved around the sun rather than the other way around"
This is a canard.
The first Heliocentric book, from 1540, by a Protestant disciple of Copernicus (Rhaeticus, I think) was directly banned.
Btw, how do you prove Heliocentrism apart from Atheism? I can see how Heliocentrism would be the only way if for instance gravitation and inertia, both depending on mass on a very macro level were the only possible causes for movements in such macro levels as heavenly bodies. I can't see how this would exclude God and Angels, supposing He and they exist, from making the Geocentric universe we actually directly see and observe.
7:24 Don't you think one could consider letting Christa Pike go after 31 years?
A young immigrant shot a Swede much more cold bloodedly, and he was only given 14 years ...
9:49 Speaking of martyrs, do you think Colleen Slemmer was one?
I haven't come across one line of written or oral testimony from Pike or Shipp that Slemmer cursed or even called any of them names.
She seems to have spent the entire time she even could talk just trying to plead with them not to do it ...
If someone were starting to kill me, I could imagine myself saying things like "mais qu'est-ce que tu fais, salaud" or things ... Colleen Anne Slemmer seems to have been chemically free from that.
Christa Pike had a court hearing about Slemmer, to establish her own guilt. I think she should have a church hearing about Slemmer, establishing this girl's holiness ...
11:51 "I just can't believe the particulars of that religion or any religion. I just think humans are too flawed to have worked out the truth about these things. And I certainly don't think that the people who were alive during Jesus's time were somehow privileged over other people in history to be the only ones alive at the same time as the son of God."
Too flawed to have worked out these things, I hear you.
The massacre in Schletz, if you ask me, was before 2166 BC, which is carbon dated to 4933 BC, and that means 792 years after the Flood or 391 years after the confusion of tongues.
Very recent acts of a God, known to have hated that kind of violence, especially recent back when people lived that long, you might think people would have learned a lesson and they didn't.
B u t ... why would God become Man not constitute a privilege for those living during His earthly life?
It's not as if we were saying the people back then were "privileged enough to merit" His presence, far from it. Roman Crucifixion is too like the Vultures of Nimrod in Babel / Göbekli Tepe. No, He came down the precise moment when His own death was the only thing that could outweigh the evil so much God didn't have to end the world right back then. Basically another Flood, except NOT in water.
15:02 Saner voices on the Left?
I heard some valid concerns by Kristi Burke about elections, so I approached her. If she'd go against abortion and for school liberties, I'd have endorsed her over MAGA because of economic and social justice issues. Nope ...
16:13 "I think you could argue that new secular religions have taken their place."
At least Spinozans in SS and Martin Bormann were honest about it. That's what Gottgläubig meant, and Pope Pius XI was disgusted by abuse of the word.
The French Positivists were also honest about it. Alas the religion that Charles Maurras died in.
But when Komsomol pretended to fight "religion" rather than Theism, that's kind of when Pentecostals say "Christianity is not a religion" ...
16:49 "Ironically, I think wokeness also has some roots in Christianity. This is difficult to prove, but I think of it as a deranged offshoot of Christianity."
If the value system of Hemant Mehta ows anything to Jainism (as I think they do), it's pretty obvious.
Göbekli Tepe is very much in the Bible if you ask me, but this videast goes through three wrong theories ...
SHAREABLE:* Is Göbekli Tepe in the Bible?
BLK SHP Bible Talk | 3 June 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JUFrlAptoHk
I went through the transscription.
None of the alternatives you mentioned was [that] Göbekli Tepe is Babel and does fit in the Biblical timeline for Babel.
That's my position.
Carbon date 9600 BC is close to 350 after the Flood, Noah's death, when Babel began.
Carbon date 8000 BC is close to 401 after the Flood, Peleg's birth, when Babel ended.
Now, I say close to, though my tables treat it as identic, insofar as I read somewhere Babel was 40 years and this space if 51 years. I read somewhere, possibly else, that the confusion of tongues had happened seven years before Peleg was born. This would mean, taking both together, that Babel began 354 years after the Flood and ended 394 years after the Flood.
I'm using the chronology of the martyrology for Christmas Day, namely 942 years between Flood and birth of Abraham, namely a Genesis 11 either Samarian or LXX without the Second Cainan. Julius Africanus did the calculations up to Abraham's birth, St. Jerome continued it, this chronology was given in the Nativity narrative of Historia Scholastica, a Biblical history resumé (which also features Ninus and Romulus, but calls mentions of extra-Biblical history "incidentia" ... and from there into the Martyrology Usuardus in the late 1400's and from there (with exclusion of Fall of Troy) into Roman Martyrology, promulgated for the whole Latin Church mostly after Usuardus.
Göbekli Tepe is on the edge of a plain, which can also be described as a plateau, it is West of any candidate for Noah's landing place, so fits "removed from the East" (the usual meaning of miqqedem with verbs of movement), and the plain is inside Euphrates and Tigris, so fits that the plain was in the land of Shinar.
2:30 It doesn't agitate me in the least.
Let's take the two limit dates, carbon wise and Biblical chronology wise. I will use my approximations, with the inexact implications that Babel was 51 rather than 40 years.
Because, I already have a table** for this:
- II—III
- Starting out 2608 BC
- 43.443 pmC, 9500 BC
- 2591 BC
- 46.223 pmC, dated as 8970 BC
- 2574 BC
- 48.998 pmC, dated as 8471 BC
- 2557 BC
- 51.766 pmC, dated as 8000 BC
An object which had 43.443 pmC when it left the atmosphere, immediately had 6892 years of carbon age when it was recent.***
And object which had 51.766 pmC only had 5443 years when it was recent.
12:25 Yes, from Mt Judi, mmunicipality of Cizre in Turkish Armenia, it's c. 300 km Westward to remove from the East to Göbekli Tepe.
Which makes Babel a great fit, and "altar of Noah" a not great fit at all.
* This is an extract from a longer version, which BLK SHP Bible Talk reserved for the members.
** See Newer tables, part 2 being : Flood to Joseph in Egypt
*** Part 1 of same, Preliminaries gives formulas, both for time implication (instant age or decay time) to pmC and for pmC to time implication. I used the latter and rounded here.
Thursday, November 19, 2026
There are some Jewish Organisations I don't like ... what about the people?
If You Don't Like Jewish People, Watch This
Kylie Ora Lobell | 19 Nov. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kzAew94apo8
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @hglundahl
- Jews should convert to Jesus Christ.
If in Israel, they should seek peace with Palestinians, not oppression.
If in Europe or America, they should stay.
Palestinians are Hebrews of two other religions than Judaism and Samarianism.
One of them the true one, Christianity.
Jews have done some evil as "money brokers" (bankers, stockmarket etc) and as shrinks. While waiting for Jews to convert, I wish them the best of success in music, linguistic and some other niche things.
Some guys thought that Israel was the best way to avoid whatever happened up to some dates in the first half of 1945, and since then a certain 7 October seems to have proven that wrong. That was the largest killing of Jews anywhere since 1945 ...
One more thing. In Germany and France, you may of course be grandchild of someone who was a captive. That doesn't give you the right to be nasty to everyone whose grandparents were more or less into NSDAP instead ... I stopped liking Simon Wiesenthal Center after they targetted John Demyanyuk.
- John Beerschoten
- @JohnBeerschoten-qf8bz
- Do you not know what the Hannibal Directive on October 7 2023 means? Jesus man, do your homework.
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @JohnBeerschoten-qf8bz I look it up.
"The Hannibal Directive: A Recipe for War Crimes"
My point still stands, this crime happened to people in Israel, not in rue Copernic, Paris 1980, where only 4 died, and France is still talking about it.
Whether the perpetrator was only Al Qassem or Al Qassem in combination with Israeli soldiers, it was in Israel that the victims were confronted with that.
@JohnBeerschoten-qf8bz Btw, my name isn't Jesus, and I also don't support taking His Holy Name in vain.
0:59 If you want a somewhat realistic view of how Jews could come off at times, maybe look at Arabs today.
You basically just said that 109 "countries" (exaggerated if you count by modern countries) were "the ones who were the jerk" ...
When Jews in Trier, very few of them, but it's very probable it was they, killed St. Simon of Trent, that doesn't look like what Jews are imaged today ... more as something between Muslim terrorists and illuminists. Or whatever was going on on Epstein island.
But that act is not the story of an expulsion, the Jews in Trier were so few, they were held collectively responsible. No one left the city and they didn't get all much further than the courtroom.
St. Lewis IX banned Jewish money-lenders. Now, the problem isn't they wanted money back. It's somewhat worse that they asked interest (Leviticus 25). Even worse, a debtor was pretty harshly pushed to ask for bankrupcy by creditors (in that case Jews, not saying Lombards were better) saying basically "work hard and eat ramen" ... that was one of the actual bans. Another one by St. Pius V involved Jews having played sexologists and church profaners. And unlike the Spanish expulsion, that one wasn't all that hard, he made exceptions for two ghettos (Rome and Ancona) and allowed them 90 days. Urbino to Rieti (both of which were border cities of Papal States) are 212 km apart, and it's a diagonal, it's basically a little more than 2 km a day they had to do, as to the travelling. And the decree was made in late February, compare to this year when high temperatures were just below 20° C (17 to 19) 25 to 28 Feb. No one was forced to convert because the travel was too harsh that time.
6:41 You certainly will have JHVH as soon as you convert.
He spoke to Moses, and wrote the law in granite. He also spoke to an adulteress after writing the commandments in the sand.
- John Beerschoten
- Bla, bla, bla. what makes you think God is a person?
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @JohnBeerschoten God is three Persons.
The Creed.
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
No, I'm Not a Mormon
The "60 Second Rule" Mormon Missionaries Use to Convert
Cults to Consciousness | 2 Nov. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GA7houj5cMI
I am probably seeing this, because some eejit in France believes my Young Earth Creationism is a Mormon tenet.
So not.
I once let in Mormons, two of them, and basically immediately let them know I'm Catholic.
We discussed the Great Apostasy, and I argued, it is an end times event, leaving a visible, but diminished remnant, not a very long ago clean sweep.
I'm not sure if they came back once, they didn't come a third time, and the "older" or "tougher" was getting worried about the "younger" or "gentler" ... he didn't want me to convert him to Catholicism.
Can Every Bishop Be Traced Back to an Apostle?
Can Every Bishop Be Traced Back to an Apostle?
Jimmy Akin | 17 Nov. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vBp-NjSPwV4
I'm just noting that Michael I, via Bob Bjarnesen, traces his consecration to 1924 when Eduardo Duarte e Silva consecrated one Carlos Duarte Costa.
It seems Michael II is also the Duarte Costa line, purely pre-conciliar rite consecrations.
"it also wouldn't have been because many in the early church expected Jesus to return. I mean St. Paul initially thought that Jesus was going to return in his own lifetime. He later learned that that was not going to be the case."
Sure the old version of Pontifical Biblical Commission would have agreed on this one?
I have a hard time reconciling this with the 1915 decision ... in fact I'm not reconciling it.
2:52 The non-keeping of records couldn't be, like, a tactic to give Roman persecutors less to go on?
3:46 Given how many of the records we have end in a certain Scipione Rebiba, we know when he was consecrated bishop, namely 14 May1541, but we don't know who, that period was not the last time that someone was not kept record of.
In 1541, there could have been people needing to return to Protestant countries and who didn't care for Henry or Fredrik or Gustav to know they wer bishops and able to consecrate such ...
Abgar V, Chosroene, Not Exactly Armenia
Eusebius Quoted by Sam Shamoun · Abgar V, Chosroene, Not Exactly Armenia
A Dying King Wrote Jesus A Letter, And Jesus Answered
Fr. Carlos Peace | 16 Nov. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/AnD-w9Q2WbQ
I wasn't aware Edessa and Chosroene counted as Armenia ...
The conversion of Chosroene was a first state that was Christian, until annected by Rome.
The first state that was Christian and remained so was Armenia, far later.
Sh0e > Dan Crenshaw (but that's understating the compliments)
The Republican Reckoning | The Truth About The Midterms
Shoe0nHead | 17 Nov. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7wK8FlBZtk
Two party system ...
What about the economics of Bernie and the Pro-Life and Pro-Educational Liberties of Vance?
Oh, wait, one is blue and one is red ...
8:00 Oh, Vivek said Americans are too lazy and need to be replaced by Indians?
I can see why Groypers (a k a Nick Fuentes) commented "bye bye, Vivek" ... I suppose they would show no reluctance to offer him tickets for India, if they were one way.
28:26 I'm comparing to tacos over here.
If a typical burrito is 1 to 2 pounds (500 to 1000 g) and a typical taco in France (not US) is 350 to 500 g ...
burrito 20 USD, taco 12 € ... you check ...
30:04 Eat ramen, like we did in college, get a job ... w a i t ... most jobs aren't just done with the brain and at hours mostly at own disposal like studies ...
Ramen might be adequate for the one (college) and not the other (job) ...
30:04 "The market doesn't care what you think something 'should' cost. Only communists care"
He just called St. Thomas Aquinas and my favourite book on Fascist Economics I haven't read yet, Monsignor Seipel's Wirtschaftsethische Lehre der Kirchenväter, Communist.
"(they set prices, remember? then everybody starves, remember?"
The Holodomor wasn't done by Stalin setting prices. It also didn't mean everyone starved. The Volga region was threatened by another starvation, like back in the time when Czarist fans of Sergei Witte neglected agriculture. Stalin and Yagoda avoided a starvation in the Volga region (new capital Moscow being there) and in the regions of the old capital by imposing starvation on people who had good harvests, like Russians in Kuban and like Ukrainians all over Ukraine. But the Volga region didn't starve, so Stalin could stay in power.
And allowing the market to rule was precisely what got the earlier Holodomar, sorry, Gorta Mor, on Ireland going, along with landlords sticking literally to the contract postulating that the tenant grow wheat and potatoes and hand over the wheat and keep the potatoes. You know, the reason why New York City and even Boston Massachusetts have St. Patrick's Day Parades.
30:04 Given Crenshaw's proposal, and his being one eyed, I did a gematria check. No, he isn't the Antichrist:
D 68
C 67 120 15
R 82 200 17
E 69 260 26
N 78 330 34
S 83 410 37
H 72 480 39
A 65 540 44
W 87 620 51 [=671]
He might still be "tribe of Dan", though ...
33:09 There was a certain Maggie Thatcher who made sure workers got stock shares in their own company ...
At least she proposed it ... and I liked it.
33:55 One job should be enough ... as for both in the couple?
Men paid so much that women don't need to find a job other than next pregnancy?
I have known a National Socialist (so self described) who said so. She unfriended me on having said, basically, I have no right to the Great Goy-Certificate (grosses Goj-Ausweis) ...
Hoch Dollfuss!
35:16 I heartily find the comparison of Anakin Skywalker to Fascism distasteful.
It's insulting to the memory of Il Duce!
He's closer to Yagüe and Richthoven, perpetrators at Badajoz and Guernica, two right wing participants in the Spanish Crusade I'm not honouring ...
36:52 I'm as careful about predictions as Gildor about advice ... sorry!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)