Assorted retorts from yahoo boards and elsewhere
co-authors are other participants quoted. I haven't changed content of thr replies, but quoted it part by part in my replies, interspersing each reply after relevant part. Sometimes I have also changed the order of replies with my retorts, so as to prioritate logical/topical over temporal/chronological connexions. That has also involved conflating more than one message. I have also left out mere insults.
Pages
- Home
- Other blogs, same writer
- A thread from Catholic.com (more may be added)
- Answering Steve Rudd
- Have these dialogues taken place? Yes.
- Copyright issues on blogposts with shared copyright
- I think I wrote a mistaken word somewhere on youtube - or perhaps not
- What is Expertise? Some Things It is Not.
- It Seems Apocalypse is Explained in a Very Relevant Part
- Dialoguing Mainly with Adversaries
- Why do my Posts Right Here Not Answer YOUR Questio...
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
No, I'm Not a Mormon
The "60 Second Rule" Mormon Missionaries Use to Convert
Cults to Consciousness | 2 Nov. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GA7houj5cMI
I am probably seeing this, because some eejit in France believes my Young Earth Creationism is a Mormon tenet.
So not.
I once let in Mormons, two of them, and basically immediately let them know I'm Catholic.
We discussed the Great Apostasy, and I argued, it is an end times event, leaving a visible, but diminished remnant, not a very long ago clean sweep.
I'm not sure if they came back once, they didn't come a third time, and the "older" or "tougher" was getting worried about the "younger" or "gentler" ... he didn't want me to convert him to Catholicism.
Can Every Bishop Be Traced Back to an Apostle?
Can Every Bishop Be Traced Back to an Apostle?
Jimmy Akin | 17 Nov. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vBp-NjSPwV4
I'm just noting that Michael I, via Bob Bjarnesen, traces his consecration to 1924 when Eduardo Duarte e Silva consecrated one Carlos Duarte Costa.
It seems Michael II is also the Duarte Costa line, purely pre-conciliar rite consecrations.
"it also wouldn't have been because many in the early church expected Jesus to return. I mean St. Paul initially thought that Jesus was going to return in his own lifetime. He later learned that that was not going to be the case."
Sure the old version of Pontifical Biblical Commission would have agreed on this one?
I have a hard time reconciling this with the 1915 decision ... in fact I'm not reconciling it.
2:52 The non-keeping of records couldn't be, like, a tactic to give Roman persecutors less to go on?
3:46 Given how many of the records we have end in a certain Scipione Rebiba, we know when he was consecrated bishop, namely 14 May1541, but we don't know who, that period was not the last time that someone was not kept record of.
In 1541, there could have been people needing to return to Protestant countries and who didn't care for Henry or Fredrik or Gustav to know they wer bishops and able to consecrate such ...
Abgar V, Chosroene, Not Exactly Armenia
Eusebius Quoted by Sam Shamoun · Abgar V, Chosroene, Not Exactly Armenia
A Dying King Wrote Jesus A Letter, And Jesus Answered
Fr. Carlos Peace | 16 Nov. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/AnD-w9Q2WbQ
I wasn't aware Edessa and Chosroene counted as Armenia ...
The conversion of Chosroene was a first state that was Christian, until annected by Rome.
The first state that was Christian and remained so was Armenia, far later.
Sh0e > Dan Crenshaw (but that's understating the compliments)
The Republican Reckoning | The Truth About The Midterms
Shoe0nHead | 17 Nov. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7wK8FlBZtk
Two party system ...
What about the economics of Bernie and the Pro-Life and Pro-Educational Liberties of Vance?
Oh, wait, one is blue and one is red ...
8:00 Oh, Vivek said Americans are too lazy and need to be replaced by Indians?
I can see why Groypers (a k a Nick Fuentes) commented "bye bye, Vivek" ... I suppose they would show no reluctance to offer him tickets for India, if they were one way.
28:26 I'm comparing to tacos over here.
If a typical burrito is 1 to 2 pounds (500 to 1000 g) and a typical taco in France (not US) is 350 to 500 g ...
burrito 20 USD, taco 12 € ... you check ...
30:04 Eat ramen, like we did in college, get a job ... w a i t ... most jobs aren't just done with the brain and at hours mostly at own disposal like studies ...
Ramen might be adequate for the one (college) and not the other (job) ...
30:04 "The market doesn't care what you think something 'should' cost. Only communists care"
He just called St. Thomas Aquinas and my favourite book on Fascist Economics I haven't read yet, Monsignor Seipel's Wirtschaftsethische Lehre der Kirchenväter, Communist.
"(they set prices, remember? then everybody starves, remember?"
The Holodomor wasn't done by Stalin setting prices. It also didn't mean everyone starved. The Volga region was threatened by another starvation, like back in the time when Czarist fans of Sergei Witte neglected agriculture. Stalin and Yagoda avoided a starvation in the Volga region (new capital Moscow being there) and in the regions of the old capital by imposing starvation on people who had good harvests, like Russians in Kuban and like Ukrainians all over Ukraine. But the Volga region didn't starve, so Stalin could stay in power.
And allowing the market to rule was precisely what got the earlier Holodomar, sorry, Gorta Mor, on Ireland going, along with landlords sticking literally to the contract postulating that the tenant grow wheat and potatoes and hand over the wheat and keep the potatoes. You know, the reason why New York City and even Boston Massachusetts have St. Patrick's Day Parades.
30:04 Given Crenshaw's proposal, and his being one eyed, I did a gematria check. No, he isn't the Antichrist:
D 68
C 67 120 15
R 82 200 17
E 69 260 26
N 78 330 34
S 83 410 37
H 72 480 39
A 65 540 44
W 87 620 51 [=671]
He might still be "tribe of Dan", though ...
33:09 There was a certain Maggie Thatcher who made sure workers got stock shares in their own company ...
At least she proposed it ... and I liked it.
33:55 One job should be enough ... as for both in the couple?
Men paid so much that women don't need to find a job other than next pregnancy?
I have known a National Socialist (so self described) who said so. She unfriended me on having said, basically, I have no right to the Great Goy-Certificate (grosses Goj-Ausweis) ...
Hoch Dollfuss!
35:16 I heartily find the comparison of Anakin Skywalker to Fascism distasteful.
It's insulting to the memory of Il Duce!
He's closer to Yagüe and Richthoven, perpetrators at Badajoz and Guernica, two right wing participants in the Spanish Crusade I'm not honouring ...
36:52 I'm as careful about predictions as Gildor about advice ... sorry!
Let's admit he really had me for a while (as an April fool) pretending to be praying for the soul of a man validly excommunicated and not reconciled ...
WATCH THIS NOW.
The Counsel of Trent | 1 April 2026
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/hVQwAXpjy0w
Did Sebastian Munster show all the four corners of mainland on his map?
Alaska, Cape Horn, in the West, Siberia (north of Kamtchatka) and Tasmania in the East?
I'd take the four corners of land literally (though some translations have rendered eretz and terra as "earth" instead of "land" ...).
Cynoscephaloi ... description of a description of a description.
Some Africans are slit eyed to nearly Asiatic proportions and some dog breeds are slit eyed. I'd say this accounts for calling St. Christopher one, or it might be hypertrichosis making all of his face hairy.
I don't think the descriptions of St. Christopher as a doghead were limited to Eastern Orthodox (or Photian Heretics to give the 16th C. term).
At least people united at Florence would also have such icons, I think.
If the "doghead" is simply in the case of a slit eyed person or having hypertrichosis, you certainly could marry the doghead.
Those certainly come from Adam and Eve. And as for Neanderthals and Denisovans, they were married into the ancestry of the eight on the Ark. Some have however suggested rape. Could you marry an angelic being? No. Could you marry the child of a human woman and an angelic being? Maybe. Could you marry someone the offspring of such? Probably one of the sons of Noah did.
Past middle of the short.
Will someone give you the news that Luther died in February?
Yep, someone did.
Was the project for the Gregorian calendar already proposed by 1546? Didn't know.
It got into force just in time to change the death of St. Teresa from 5th to 15th October.
Sunday, November 15, 2026
Some don't know St. Thomas was Young Earth Creationist
The video seems to be a pretty accurate summary of St. Thomas' biography and its "Sitz im Leben" compared to cultural history in a larger perspective. So, my mention in the comment below isn't criticising anything Robert Barron actually says in this video. Initially, there is a very good reset of expectations about what this period was like. And I mean an excellent one.
Bishop Robert Barron | Thomas Aquinas
14 Nov. 2026 | Peterson Academy / Bishop Robert Barron / Jordan B Peterson Clips
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zxF7WxycLz0
You are aware that St. Thomas was Geocentric and Young Earth Creationist, right?
Just mentioning, because I think Robert Barron (whom I sometimes nickname Robber Baron of Theology) is Heliocentric, Big Bangist, Deep Spacer, Deep Timer and Evolutionist, whether he includes Adam in such a process or not.
- I
- Tom Greene
- @tomgreene1843
- Tom Greene
- Didn't know he was a ''Young earth ' man.
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @hglundahl
- @tomgreene1843 He had taken oath on maintaining, apart from the Bible:
- Sentences by Peter the Lombard, a Theology manual
- Decretum Gratiani, a manual of Canon right
- Historia Scholastica, by Peter the Eater / Petrus Comestor, a Biblical (mainly) history, where the Gospel part starts with a notice later incorporated into the Roman Martyrology:
"Anno a creatione mundi, quando in principio Deus creavit caelum et terram, quinquies millesimo centesimo nonagesimo nono; a diluvio autem, anno bis millesimo nongentesimo quinquagesimo septimo; a nativitate Abrahae, anno bis millesimo quintodecimo; a Moyse et egressu populi Israel de Aegypto, anno millesimo quingentesimo decimo; ..."
Jesus is born 5199 after the Beginning, when God created heaven and earth, 2957 after the Flood, 2015 after the birth of Abraham, 1510 after the Exodus ...
I think this meets the criteria of Young Earth Creationism, unless you suggest he was unfaithful to his oath. Like one can say that Fr. Teilhard arguably was unfaithful to the Antimodernist oath, but unlike St. Thomas, he's not a saint.
- II
- Christiaan
- @Christiaan-w8p
- Christiaan
- Classic ad hominem argument. If you're not willing to learn, why are you even here?
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @Christiaan-w8p To your last question: because I know.
- III
- Patrick Dillon
- @patrickdillon9188
- Patrick Dillon
- So then you can add to you little narrow view of science history the consensus that In 1200 AD, virtually 100% of scholars and astronomers across Europe, the Islamic world, and Asia held a geocentric view of the universe. While an exact headcount does not exist because the modern profession of "scientist" had not yet been invented, placing Earth at the center of the cosmos was the universal consensus among educated thinkers of the era.
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @patrickdillon9188 OK.
For some reason, you then prefer to consider St. Thomas just materially Geocentric and Young Earth Creationist while being formally "pro-scientific-consensus" ...
Would you mind showing me exactly where in St. Thomas this exact stance is expressed, on what level and for what kind of purpose? If at all?
I obviously argue that he was formally Geocentric and Young Earth Creationist. Can you prove me wrong?
- Patrick Dillon
- @hglundahl no, I can't prove you wrong, your debating skills are just too powerful to contend with.
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @patrickdillon9188 Like having the facts on my side?
Apart from that, I have been beaten in debates.
Some Pretend to Know Exactly What Greta's Laughter Means
Neil Sean says she "is dumped" ... maybe sth like "she will be dumped" but that's not yet a visible fact.
GRETA IS DUMPED BY THE CROWD SHE RIPPED OFF AFTER THIS #gretathunberg #fake #news
NEIL SEAN'S DAILY NEWS HEADLINES | 15 Nov. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TDR7r6z6_4A
If she was manipulated, it was least of all by people who wanted fame.
School teachers in Sweden were pretty certainly pushing the worst Al Gore scenarios, taken straight from the 1970's comic book The City of Shifting Waters.
None of them want fame for themselves, all of them want to save the planet, and she volunteered to push the message.
2:04 The "people around her" were with 100 % certainty school teachers at a well viewed Swedish school in the capital.
Globala gymnasiet - her high school - was founded in 2004 and piques itself on using only renewable resources. They have a mast radiator and educate in radio communications. They also have a vegan menue for those who want (which obviously involved Greta Thunberg).
So, it's highly ironic if people who pretend her manipulated back then suggest she should have gone back to school. Those, if anyone, were the people manipulating her.
It's also near Communist to pretend that when minors who are someone's progeny share values or beliefs not those of the broad public with their parents (who did put her in that high school) this is somehow parents manipulating their children. It's a very usual charge when it comes to home schoolers being, for instance, Young Earth Creationist or Pro-Life.
Because they knew that it was just a grift.
That's one reading.
Not the most charitable one. Not a necessary one.
For someone who has been in Israeli prisons and been taken into police custody from actions in Germany and in Denmark, the memory of those idyllic days may have been a welcome relief.
Sure "cut" suggests that she may have been aware of your interpretation, not necessarily that she actually shares it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)