The video seems to be a pretty accurate summary of St. Thomas' biography and its "Sitz im Leben" compared to cultural history in a larger perspective. So, my mention in the comment below isn't criticising anything Robert Barron actually says in this video. Initially, there is a very good reset of expectations about what this period was like. And I mean an excellent one.
Bishop Robert Barron | Thomas Aquinas
14 Nov. 2026 | Peterson Academy / Bishop Robert Barron / Jordan B Peterson Clips
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zxF7WxycLz0
You are aware that St. Thomas was Geocentric and Young Earth Creationist, right?
Just mentioning, because I think Robert Barron (whom I sometimes nickname Robber Baron of Theology) is Heliocentric, Big Bangist, Deep Spacer, Deep Timer and Evolutionist, whether he includes Adam in such a process or not.
- I
- Tom Greene
- @tomgreene1843
- Tom Greene
- Didn't know he was a ''Young earth ' man.
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @hglundahl
- @tomgreene1843 He had taken oath on maintaining, apart from the Bible:
- Sentences by Peter the Lombard, a Theology manual
- Decretum Gratiani, a manual of Canon right
- Historia Scholastica, by Peter the Eater / Petrus Comestor, a Biblical (mainly) history, where the Gospel part starts with a notice later incorporated into the Roman Martyrology:
"Anno a creatione mundi, quando in principio Deus creavit caelum et terram, quinquies millesimo centesimo nonagesimo nono; a diluvio autem, anno bis millesimo nongentesimo quinquagesimo septimo; a nativitate Abrahae, anno bis millesimo quintodecimo; a Moyse et egressu populi Israel de Aegypto, anno millesimo quingentesimo decimo; ..."
Jesus is born 5199 after the Beginning, when God created heaven and earth, 2957 after the Flood, 2015 after the birth of Abraham, 1510 after the Exodus ...
I think this meets the criteria of Young Earth Creationism, unless you suggest he was unfaithful to his oath. Like one can say that Fr. Teilhard arguably was unfaithful to the Antimodernist oath, but unlike St. Thomas, he's not a saint.
- II
- Christiaan
- @Christiaan-w8p
- Christiaan
- Classic ad hominem argument. If you're not willing to learn, why are you even here?
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @Christiaan-w8p To your last question: because I know.
- II
- Patrick Dillon
- @patrickdillon9188
- Patrick Dillon
- So then you can add to you little narrow view of science history the consensus that In 1200 AD, virtually 100% of scholars and astronomers across Europe, the Islamic world, and Asia held a geocentric view of the universe. While an exact headcount does not exist because the modern profession of "scientist" had not yet been invented, placing Earth at the center of the cosmos was the universal consensus among educated thinkers of the era.
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @patrickdillon9188 OK.
For some reason, you then prefer to consider St. Thomas just materially Geocentric and Young Earth Creationist while being formally "pro-scientific-consensus" ...
Would you mind showing me exactly where in St. Thomas this exact stance is expressed, on what level and for what kind of purpose? If at all?
I obviously argue that he was formally Geocentric and Young Earth Creationist. Can you prove me wrong?
No comments:
Post a Comment