Wednesday, October 28, 2026

We Have the Universe We Observe


Why Didn't Anybody Tell Me?
philhellenes | 24 Oct. 2009
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jyjNXdEGjO4


Jammsbro
@Jammsbro1
I remember the moment I became an atheist after 20 years of religion. I was standing in work, it was 1:22 on a Monday afternoon and after two years of difficult questions and thoughts it suddenly came over me like a wave, it can all happen without any god. It was the most profound moment in my life.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@hglundahl
I remember one night awake after a discussion, night to 24th August 2001, when I realised God could do the Universe THAT WE SEE without any Heliocentrism or ultramechanism.

Key concept : if angels can move stars (if they exist, by definition they can) how do I know the "parallax" and "annual aberration" of alpha Centauri (a movement of c. 20 arc seconds overall and 0.76 arc seconds compared to other stars around it back and forth each year) is only a double optical illusion due to Earth moving? I don't. Ergo, Earth need not be moving!

I

jursamaj
@jursamaj
@hglundahl 2 problems with the "God could have done that" argument:

1. Since God is defined as omnipotent, God could have done anything any way. That doesn't explain anything.

2. If all the evidence we see leads us to false conclusions, and that evidence is supplied by God, that makes God a massive liar. That's hardly a being worthy of worship.

3

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@jursamaj 1) For moving a star, even an angel is adequate (though God's the one moving heaven around earth each day).

2) The evidence doesn't "lead" per se to false conclusions, it leads some people to false conclusions through their false preconceptions. Does NOT make God or His angels liars.

Kasperi
@khakala97
@hglundahl God being omnipotent, omnipresent and loving, she would obviously make it so that NO ONE who loves him would be led astray.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@khakala97 Those who are in a state of grace, that is truly love God, do get a protection.

Most do not. That's where the protection is denied.

Kasperi
@hglundahl even if that was true, none would ever know if they were the ones chosen. That is ultimately a waste of time.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@khakala97 We are, usually, excepting personal privilege, not meant to know in this life if we are the chosen ones.

We are meant to long for heaven and fear hell.

Kasperi
@hglundahl you will one day not be able to realize you wasted all your days wishing for a divine dictator's favouritism to be towards you. The longer you hold these beliefs, the harder it is to stop throwing your life away. Good luck, keep an open mind! Best wishes.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@khakala97 I have my life de facto in more than one way wasted - not by my religion, but by people like you, trying to keep me back from making my money as a writer for my religion, and trying to keep me generally in a position of inferiority, as long as I refuse to apostasise.

But suppose I were wrong - and I'm not - at least I have lived a more fun life than some of you, like one ex-Pentecostal now atheist and now wasting his life an sucking up to his shrinks.

@khakala97 Not to mention the guys wasting their lives on masks, tests and other paraphernalia of Covid restrictions ... your profile picture just reminded me ...

Kasperi
@hglundahl and now I have a little less hope for you than before this comment

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@khakala97 I'd prefer people like you having no such hope at all.

Kasperi
@hglundahl it is sad that the only way for you to realize what I mean is to open your mind, and every comment pushes you away from being open to new ideas. This is unproductive, bye!

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@khakala97 Oh, you are leaving - is that a promise?

By the way, Heliocentrism and Evolution are not new ideas to me, they are in my biography old errors I got out of.

Kasperi
@hglundahl oh no constant regression. Soon your knowledge will match your world view - a bronze age one!

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@khakala97 Indeed, no constant regression ongoing ... or did you miss a comma or exclamation mark after "oh no" perhaps?

If you pretend someone should be ashamed of a bronze age world view, how about reading a post entitled "Bronze Age, the New Slur" on a blog entitled "Φιλολoγικά/Philologica" - it is from nearly nine and a half years ago, and some of you still don't learn that referring to early parts of the Bible as from the Bronze Age doesn't in the least make me ashamed of them.

Kasperi
@hglundahl it is sad that the only way for you to realize what I mean is to open your mind, and every comment pushes you away from being open to new ideas. This is unproductive, bye!

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@khakala97 Oh, you are leaving - is that a promise?

By the way, Heliocentrism and Evolution are not new ideas to me, they are in my biography old errors I got out of.

Kasperi
@hglundahl oh no constant regression. Soon your knowledge will match your world view - a bronze age one!

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@khakala97 Indeed, no constant regression ongoing ... or did you miss a comma or exclamation mark after "oh no" perhaps?

If you pretend someone should be ashamed of a bronze age world view, how about reading a post entitled "Bronze Age, the New Slur" on a blog entitled "Φιλολoγικά/Philologica" - it is from nearly nine and a half years ago, and some of you still don't learn that referring to early parts of the Bible as from the Bronze Age doesn't in the least make me ashamed of them.

II

TradyAch
@TradyAch_Yo
@hglundahl - “…without any Heliocentrism or ultramechanism.” > Those are not real terms people use in mainstream physics or philosophy; nor are they actually real words to begin with. There are only heliocentric, and I have never once heard a person utter ‘ultramechanism’ until now, do you mean physicalism instead? Scientists don’t add the ‘ism’ at the end of Heliocentric — because it’s only an adjective, not a theory.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@TradyAch_Yo Heliocentrism is a theory.

I can agree ultramechanism could be called physicalism. It's probably better rendered in English as ultramechanicism.

What I realised is, God could do without both and therefore we have the universe we actually directly observe.

TradyAch
@hglundahl Thank you for your reply.

Even if Heliocentric is a theory, it’s extremely well-supported enough for it to be true (examples: the phases of Venus; the apparent backward movements of planets; stellar parallax; mathematical predictions and gravity; etc. etc.). It wasn’t just baselessly speculative. Scientific theories are formed when it has enough good evidence for it. The fathers of the Heliocentric ‘theory’, were deeply religious(!) themselves : those being Galileo Galilei, Nicolaus Copernicus, Johannes Kepler, and Isaac Newton.

I’m not sure much about the God part myself. I’m agnostic, so I don’t whether there is deity or not that created.

Have a good day.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@TradyAch_Yo "the phases of Venus"

Perfectly compatible with Tychonian Geocentrism.

"the apparent backward movements of planets"

Or, more completely, the spirograph patterns they overall make, again, perfectly compatible with Tychonian Geocentrism.

"stellar parallax"

Unless it's a proper movement of the star made by an angel, or rather part of one, along with other misnomer "aberration".

"mathematical predictions"

Have been improving in zig zag between Geo and Helio. Geo, Ptolemy, Helio, Copernicus, Geo, Tycho Brahe, Helio, Kepler, and for Geo, Riccioli, he at least doesn't go back to less predictive than Kepler.

"and gravity;"

Why would the sheer existence of gravity argue Heliocentrism?

"The fathers of the Heliocentric ‘theory’, were deeply religious(!) themselves"

Some of them were heretics. Copernicus technically wasn't one, but he was closely associated with a disciple who was. Kepler (like Brahe), was Lutheran. Isaac Newton seems to have been both tending to Arianism and to Superstition.

Galileo gave a wrong view of Scripture, the process on Heliocentrism in 1633 might just have been a way to get him off the hook in much deeper waters of heresy (excuse the mixed metaphor).

@TradyAch_Yo Thank you for yours, by the way!

Sunday, October 25, 2026

Flood of Noah, Iridium Line


the world's scariest rock feature
Astrid Lundberg | 22 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/i_q4_1hFw84


There is one place where you have the iridium line, Kreide / Cretaceous below it and Palaeogene above it.

It's in Yacoraite, and the fauna above and below is exactly the same, sweet water slugs being a notable part of it.

I venture that both iridium lines (K-T / K - PG and P-T, Permian to Triassic) are one and the same line and from the Flood.

It raining glass in that event doesn't surprise me in the least.

Flowers were blooming ... on what hemisphere?

If on the Northern*, this would coincide neatly with Noah's Flood coming in Spring.**

The Sun would have gone out less than months if raining Flood waters cleared up the débris from this.

But if the Sun was in effect out when the forty day rain was giving 60 000 mm per 24 h (60 m higher water levels each day, apart from drainage), if the rain fall intensity generated some heat, obviously that would have come handy to keep the passangers on the Ark from freezing to death.




* Bingo, she said it a few seconds later.

** The Bible says:

In the six hundredth year of the life of Noe, in the second month, in the seventeenth day of the month, all the fountains of the great deep were broken up, and the flood gates of heaven were opened
[Genesis 7:11]


Haydock comment says:

... This second month is, by some, supposed to be the month of May; by others, that of November. ...


Seems to be May. Or more precisely:

Iyar First day 11 April to 11 May / Last day 9 May to 8 June

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hebrew_calendar

No, Evangelicals are NOT Worsening the Illiteracy Crisis of Wheatley High School


Assorted retorts from yahoo boards and elsewhere: No, Evangelicals are NOT Worsening the Illiteracy Crisis of Wheatley High School · New blog on the kid: Continuing the Tirade of Genetically Modified Sceptic, but Discission, Not Video Comment

Yes, Evangelicals Are Worsening the Illiteracy Crisis
Genetically Modified Skeptic | 14 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g42H2pF5zuM


1:02 C. S. Lewis would have agreed on that one.

Don't use long words when you can use short ones. Don't implement promises, keep them.

He was somewhat sensitive to prole critics. When he was asking what "stirabout" was (correct answer: porridge), he was taken to be affected. Coming from a pretty upper class* home, he had simply never heard it. He'd have been proud to use it if he had known it.

1:37 Did he ever even give an example?

I think Grand Canyon isn't one. "1 billion years missing" between two of the layers, plus, I don't think it has much Mesozoic or Tertiary.

If you can't refute, a FacePalm like Milo gave is always a rhetoric promise one is coming.

I'm part time homeschooled by ma. She was a ninth grade med student and working in hospitals as "intern" (does the word exist in English?) for most of my childhood and early parts of my teens. She was Young Earth Creationist, and certainly no mediocrity at science.

I was learning the laws of Mendel in what would have been 3rd or 4th grade (homeschooled parts of 4th grade, but it could have been in parallel with 3rd grade school chores).

3:28 I look the school up:

More than 60 years after Brown v. Board of Education, more than 1 million Black and Hispanic students study in Texas classrooms that include few to no white students. State leaders and education officials are working to give all students more educational opportunities but have largely abandoned racial integration as a tool for equity.

Wheatley High School**
https://schools.texastribune.org/districts/houston-isd/wheatley-high-school/demographics/


Neither Ebonics nor Spanish nor Spanglish is the spoken language that standard English is a written form of.

That very obviously affects the mastery of English.

And by the way, neither is heavily dialectal English among white populations, Ozarks is not Texas, but you know what I mean.

The students of these schools, I've taught at an all-white but heavily rural one in Sweden, do not think of school as a way to a good future, and they in their turn don't go all that far to receive instruction which they don't think will benefit them. And while I wasn't there at their peak of investments, I don't think many countries in the West have the kind of resources that really would be needed to get students inspiring teachers (I wasn't one, I was counting on inspired students and not finding them).

5:09 Mississippi wasn't dealing with large groups that read very much less well than a very significant portion.

Mississippi was as such a backwater, and they were taking this as a team effort to come out of that backwater.

Just as the school I taught at had done in the sixties.

Houston isn't a backwater, literacy significantly exists, and the students the poor teacher was crying about are people who can very realistically say "that won't be me" ...

6:22 I am looking at the funding claim you made about Texas.

Texas public schools are funded primarily from local governments. In the 2023–2024 school year, the most recent year of available data, about 47.7% of Texas public school funding came from local sources like property taxes. Another 38.6% came through state programs, and the federal government provided the remaining 13.7%. Altogether, public schools in Texas received $89.4 billion in funding, or $16,200 per student.

How are public schools in Texas funded?
USA Facts | Updated Sep. 30, 2026
https://usafacts.org/answers/how-are-public-schools-in-the-us-funded/state/texas/


This summer, Texas began rolling out $1 billion in public funding that eligible families can put toward private education expenses.

Taxpayers are funding private school tuition. It's helping classical Christian schools expand
By: The Associated Press | Posted 1:08 PM, Oct 21, 2026
https://www.kxxv.com/news/texas-news/taxpayers-are-funding-private-school-tuition-its-helping-classical-christian-schools-expand


So, one billion out of 89.4 billion is "draining"?

I tend to believe you your homeschooling parents neglected maths!

My part time homeschooling mother very much didn't!

6:46 "on the right side of history"

O K ... you ditched belief in God and became a bit too unsceptic about Historicism.

You know claims that history has a direction. Sure, Christianity makes some claims we can't be sceptic about, like it began in Eden and will pass by Armageddon before it gets better, but I mean other claims about history. Like "Lincoln was the right side of history" (I came to think of how much the North states case has to do with Capitalism and the South with rural solidarity after being reminded of the Irish Holodomor, sorry Gorta Mór by Capitalism). Or "Fascism is the wrong side of history" (note, I said Fascism, not National Socialism ... but those guys definitely thought of themselves quite a bit too much as being "the right side of history" ...)

History isn't a moral arbiter. It's not a good replacement for a Creator creating us in His image on where we get morals from.

LGBTQ would by now involve the T of Trans, and that advocacy would probably put actual guys into girls' locker rooms ...

6:53 "science tells us what's real, compassion what's right"

1) This puts "right" outside the realm of "real".
2) Science competes with science, as Milo Rossi illustrated by responding to a scientific claim by creationists with a Facepalm.
3) Compassion competes with compassion, as can be seen from the Christa Pike case.

So, I'm not a Humanist, I'm a Christian, and will remain so.

9:04 I'm not a 100 % fan of ACE social sciences.

However, before they were in the field, a social science teacher had actually made me part time (age 13 up to 15) nearly National Socialist.

She also taught history in grade 7 or 8, whichever it was, and her complaints about National Socialism include the encouragement for mothers to stay at home.

In other words, Social Science came with a very loaded agenda well before ACE came with their loaded agenda in that subject.

Their Loch Ness gaffe is on the level of public school gaffes about history in France. Have you heard a Church council decided women have souls, or that 9 million witches were burned?

Well, that's a very indirect and distorted access to the actual data in either case. The council, during a pause, corrected a young bishop on grammar, yes, a woman can be called "homo" (Latin for man) because it means "human being" (as Americans pronounce "man" in this sense). The number comes from taking a very small principality of Holy Roman Empire, multiplying that rate by all the current human population and then that again by so many centuries (despite the same locality having no big witch burnings in other centuries), which also involves a misreading about when they began.

And yet feminists will gladly put this kind of thing out in public schools.

10:32 That's about as sensible*** as saying French tax payers paid for the jewels of the King's sister.

148 864 livres on three to four years on 5 billion livres per year.

Or 1 billion dollar on a total school spending in Texas of 89.4 billion dollars.




To be continued? I stopped at 10:32 out of 24 minutes, but he just reaffirmed his bad maths, so I think this is the right place to stop./HGL





Resources on feminist fake propaganda: What Were the Witch-hunts Really Like? and (in French) Pour mon prof de latin, les coupables de cette confusion étaient les Lumières





* Actually middle class. Upper middle class, probably, but still middle class. Lawyer, not landowner. But 19th C, even upper middle class could have servants. Now, not so much, and you think "upper class" even if it wasn't.
** Also states that "the campus student population was 61.5% Black and 96.4% economically disadvantaged."
*** His point was tax payers were paying that pretty small ACE school. Which is obviously a very minuscule part of the 1 billion dollar overall.

Thursday, October 22, 2026

Jimmy Akin Disingenious or Just Naive?


Can Catholics Believe in a Literal Six-Day Creation?
Jimmy Akin | 22 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4X_4c7yneC0


Let me break down a few things about 100 + years ago.

In 1920, a Jesuit in Paris got imprimatur from his bishop (not from Rome) to publish a Dictionnaire de Théologie catholique.

In it on Hexaëmeron, he proposed, for what I thought the first time, the Framework hypothesis, or "six days is a literary form" ... but he did go through the earlier theories and what he thought wrong with them. I was wrong by one year, French Dominicans in École biblique of Jerusalem were proposing this already in 1919.

This is by the way my view on when the Great Apostasy began ... but only small scale. Or was prepared.

Now the earlier theories were:

  • six literal days directly continguous to the first act of creation ("literalism")
  • the six days are long periods ("périodisme" / "day age theory")
  • the six days were literal, but a restoration of creation after a disaster after a longer existance of heaven and earth than what came after ("gap theory")


EACH had defenders in written publications up to 1890's, and the only which went back to before Lyell, before the 1830's, was the first one. In France or specifically Paris (I think the latter), literalism was still prevailing in the 1860's and day age had taken the upper hand in the 1880's.

In 1909, the most famous defender of day age, Fulcran Vigouroux, answered dubia in Rome, and he stated in answer VIII (I think) not that day age was a perfectly licit interpretation, but that it was semantically or philologically possible and could be discussed freely, so both with full endorsement and full rejection, between theologians.

In the exact same year, the Pope, St. Pius X, canonised St. Clement Maria Hofbauer. His doctor, a convert from Judaism, a good friend of his, was one of the guys enumerated in the 1920 article as defending literalism.

Johannes Emmanuel Veith.

Now the Jesuit, his name was Mangenot, by the way, Émile Mangenot, also gave a breakdown on what he thought was wrong with each theory previous to his own framework theory.

Literalism - the Pyrenees are far older than the Alps, and even so there was not enough water to cover the Pyrenees to full height. In other words, if you could argue that the Alps had risen after the Flood, you couldn't do so for the Pyrenees, where the height is incompatible with Genesis 7:19—20. Notably, if the current height was the one back in the Flood. But he argued it must be, the Pyrenees were flatter than the Alps, because they had been as pointed at first and then worn down by time. I'd argue the Pyrenees are flatter because they rose by a different process, if folding by a different degree of folding.

Day Age — all attempts to identify creation days with known geologic periods or eras or epochs had failed.

Gap theory — no major disaster at the beginning of the Quaternary.

I agree on both of these, with a caveat that a defender of Gap Theory could try to exaggerate the importance of the Younger Dryas if he wanted.

Two more things.

1) For the full position of Fulcran Vigouroux, let's not stop at Day Age. He also believed in a large regional Flood, universal as to mankind but not earth, and survival of pre-Flood fauna and flora elsewhere, and in some kind of species fixism. He also believed that Genesis 5 was strict chronology, but Genesis 11 could contain gaps (beyond the only some versions omission of II Cainan). If needed. Preliminarily, he considered Adam had been created c. 5500 BC, using the full LXX chronology. He never got any indication that Genesis 11 actually needed more time, and he never retracted taking these chapters literally, and so he never backtracked on Adam in 5500 BC. He also never got any chance of defending a regional only Flood, as he had done by 1909 for the word yom in the Day Age interpretation.

2) At this time no one had seen any carbon dates. No one had any reason to doubt that a Neanderthal or a Cro Magnon, if fully human (denying which I consider another part of apostasy), were alive after 5500 BC. Even with the two Old Earth theories. (Cardinal Wiseman was the more famous one for Gap Theory).

Now, if a Neanderthal dates by carbon to 47 000 BP (which one near but not in Gorham Cave does) and if he was fully human, which he was, and if the Church up to this time was right that Adam didn't live "700 000 years ago" (as per not-fully Trinitarian WLC), but c. 5500 BC or most probably later, then we cannot uphold any Old Earth theory with good logic.

Only on a young earth could carbon 14 levels have been still this low.

1:31 Where is that one?

Sounds like Framework theory.

In both the Diocese of Stockholm and the now Archdiocese of Paris (which was a Diocese in the Middle Ages), Novus Ordo Catholics have met me with an attitude as if § 283 at least exacted obsequium religiosum and therefore effectively prohibited at least openly professing and arguing for literal six days, literally 6000 to 7000 + years ago in a cosmos that's Geocentric and possibly 1 or 2 or 3 light days in radius.

3:03 How about you decide whether your version of Catholicism allows or prohibits my cases on more than one blog, but essays in English would be on

Creation vs Evolution
https://creavsevolu.blogspot.com/


for Genesis 1 to 11 being:
  • up to creation of man prophecy
  • from creation of man history
  • as history accurate (with some possible, in my view probable terminological surprises)
  • and accurate about anywhere it touches on science as in how the world always works (including Geocentrism, but there I'd prefer Joshua 10 or Romans 1 as proof texts).


When it comes to what one can believe about Adam, you are so concerned to give all the possibilities that the magisterium allows, not limited to your own position, but when it comes to making a case for literal accuracy, you are suddenly squeamish about there being other positions than yours. I have not hidden your exposé of "Adam as representative" on my blog.

And I have made an update on that not necessarily being your position, but it was one of three positions you exposed as possible.

I hold that the "Adam as rhetoric figure" position changes the nature of the freewill involved in the fall, collectives not enjoying freewill, so that one really reduces to Supralapsarian Calvinism, and instead of hiding "Adam as representative" I argued against it. For instance, why would an as yet unfallen humanity need to approach God by a representative?

3:56 Here is the exact quote from Pius XII, Humani Generis:

38. Just as in the biological and anthropological sciences, so also in the historical sciences there are those who boldly transgress the limits and safeguards established by the Church. In a particular way must be deplored a certain too free interpretation of the historical books of the Old Testament. Those who favor this system, in order to defend their cause, wrongly refer to the Letter which was sent not long ago to the Archbishop of Paris by the Pontifical Commission on Biblical Studies.[13] This letter, in fact, clearly points out that the first eleven chapters of Genesis, although properly speaking not conforming to the historical method used by the best Greek and Latin writers or by competent authors of our time, do nevertheless pertain to history in a true sense, which however must be further studied and determined by exegetes; the same chapters, (the Letter points out), in simple and metaphorical language adapted to the mentality of a people but little cultured, both state the principal truths which are fundamental for our salvation, and also give a popular description of the origin of the human race and the chosen people. If, however, the ancient sacred writers have taken anything from popular narrations (and this may be conceded), it must never be forgotten that they did so with the help of divine inspiration, through which they were rendered immune from any error in selecting and evaluating those documents.


I get the feeling that he is a canon lawyer who is out of his depth and makes concessions without knowing exactly what they mean, but he restricts them in such a way that they end up meaning "it's history, but the telling is somewhat sketchy and can contain figures of speech" ...

The wording "simple and metaphoric" is not exactly enlightening, and "adapted to the mentality of a people but little cultured" is not very relevant. To the questions here asked.

Because you can have Walt Disney retell Paul Revere to boys reading Huey Dewey and Louie, reading from the Junior Woodchucker's handbook and that is adapted to US proletarian five to nine year olds who are a population very little cultured, but it's still an accurate story of Paul Revere as far as it goes.

I recently, after hearing El Pendón Estrellado, heard a more full and accurate retelling of Paul Revere, on a channel dedicated to the American Revolution. There was no factual contradiction to what Huey, Dewey and Louie had said.

4:18 So, Genesis 1 to 11 is not Thucydides (I don't see it as all that different from Livy), and it is not Theodor Mommson (whom Pacelli must have come to know as Nuncio in Germany).

That's a very far cry from endorsing anything like a Literary Framework theory.

4:31 "but it does not favor that position."

Do you mean it does not favour the position it is accurate as far as it goes? I'd disagree about Pius XII. And I obviously disagree with that position.

Or do you just mean it does not favour the position it is a detailed account that can be used as reference for normal human curiosity? I'd agree with both you and Pius XII and on this being the actual status of genre of these chapters.

4:47 ouch

Young Earth Creationism is not just the denial of significant time (more than a week) between the first creation act and the creation of Adam.

It's also the affirmation of Abraham being in twenty-odd generations from Adam, which involves Genesis 5 and 11.

It's also the affirmation that Bronze and Iron age are post-Flood rediscoveries of metallurgy, while the original discovery by Tubal-Cain was in the pre-Flood culture we presumably haven't found yet. Or rather, I'd say, Neanderthals represent the pre-Flood about like Chingachgook represents the 18th and Winnetou the 19th CC AD. But we do not have any pre-Flood Versailles or Radebäul in our archaeology.

It's also the affirmation that carbon 14 levels have been lower and have risen since then, and this is relevant as far into the Bible as Genesis 14. Asasonthamar is Engaddi, and it's archaeology has no significant population between the Chalcolithic (carbon dated from reed mats to 3500 BC), and the Iron age. BUT in Genesis 14 there are Amorrhites there, and Abraham being c. 80, this must have been c. 1936 BC. The kind of fluctuations in atmospheric C-14 content that archaeologists acknowledge do not go down to 82 pmC, which the 1564 extra years imply.

What did Horace say about the nodding of another poet in Ho-?

Indignor quandoque bonus dormitat Homerus (had to look it up). But on this issue, you dormitas pretty often, Sir!

5:00 "Catholics are perfectly free to adopt that position."

Why then are my writings basically treated as if on the Index, when defending them?

I have plenty of essays which would not from your position be schismatic, as they don't mention my views on Novus Ordo or on who's the real Pope. I started out with it while still going to SSPX, while it enjoyed the lifting of excommunications, which is still to this day endorsing the same pope as you as being pope. Or actally earlier, but I started showing it to the parish St. Ambroise in this period. Great hospitality as to food, but not a great welcome to a Young Earth Creationist!

[the video isn't over, but I end on this question]

Wednesday, October 21, 2026

Thunberg


Assorted retorts from yahoo boards and elsewhere: Thunberg · New blog on the kid: Greta and Chronology

Greta Thunberg blasted as a ‘complete idiot’ for joining France’s riots
News24 | 18 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Seb7W7NSeUY


I'll give a somewhat fair comparison to Thunberg in France.

Imagine a Christian Zionist journalist who goes to Gaza, getting shown around by the IDF.

There are things that journalist won't be shown.

Greta was NOT in the riots in Paris, she was in protests in St. Denis.

If you know who lives in St. Denis, it's very improbable she ever got to see any looting. Or even rioting against the police.

Monday, October 19, 2026

I Have Actually Been a Teacher


French teacher's perspective on the French protests
The OuiCommunicate French Method | 18 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9YNPhRZ8Vtk


I have been a teacher.

More teachers per students actually is a legitimate concern.

By now, it's so clear that High School is not giving all who have the Baccalaureate a more decent life, so, I think the solution is fewer students, and more young people starting their "real life" or better "adult careers" ...

And please don't tell me, I need to become a teacher, I can take a class of twelve if it's friendly, but not of 20, and French schools have like 35 students per class.

In 35 students, the teacher gets less respect simply by being less audible.

Now, you have been to a teachers' school, I haven't, I jumped in twice, once for two months when a Latin teacher went to Rome, and once for a term, after another one of their teachers quit. You may know how to make a clas of 35 work, I don't. But I'm sure, even your good recipe would fail in 5 out of 6 classes of 35 in France.

So, I'm not asking for more teachers, I'm asking for more freedom to quit school and start marriage or a job or both ....

"The War on Beauty" Spoke on the War that is being made on Beauty and Righteousness


The West is in ruins
The War on Beauty | 18 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/xFUN475tVrs


Would you consider it basically kind of already was over (with some stray survivals of decency) by 1918?

I hold that the office of the Roman Caesar was "ho katekhon" and obviously the last one of the East was killed in Yekaterineburg and the last one of the West left Hofburg somewhat later, same year.

Would you also consider that, given this degradation of decency, the states around the Earth are no longer fit to mete out death penalty, as Romans 13, alluding to this, mentions "the prince" as "servant of God" ...?




What it was for?

Delaying the Great Apostasy and so giving some more generations some time to not live under the Antichrist.

Ultimately, it will come to a brutal end, and the only next peace will be when Christ arrives at the Battle of Armegeddon.




Oh, progressivism certainly is part of someone's answer.

Not God's, I would say.

Progress in Swedish takes the definite article, so "framsteget", but in a dialect I learned too late to be able to make friends in the villages, it's "framstega" ...

Take that in upper case letters, give each the number value it has in ASCII and the answer looks ugly.




Yes, indeed Jesus is the Lord and a Psalm had to say something about "nisi Dominus aedificaverit domum, in vanum laboraverunt qui aedificant eam" ...

Missa versus populum ends in tragedy


Priest Killed on Air: What Really Happened? And Pope Leo News
Eternal Life Plan | 19 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyOlp10Oa1Q


If he had been celebrating to the old and traditional altar, the exact same fall of the crucifix would not have killed him.

He celebrated to the people and further away, so he neither saw the fall, nor was close to the fulcrum, he had it in the neck at full swing.




OK, young Prevost smoked or not ... did he ever bow down to Pachamama?

Sunday, October 18, 2026

Geocentrism Revisited


The Motion of Planets and the Geocentric Model
Jason Kendall | 26 Dec. 2023
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Np9Rk3q-s_g


10:29 We see Sun, Moon and Stars moving from East to West, and we see Son, Moon and other Planets move from mostly West to East along the fix stars.

Now, the thing is, while parallactic views of things (like seeing houses move in a train ride) are possible, I would consider this possibility an insufficient argument for Earth moving.

I think only two arguments of necessity are possible.

They are opposed and depend on what youo think is the most obvious.

Both share the premiss that
  • the Geocentric especially Tychonian Ricciolian movements are too complex for being simple products of automatic processes like inertia or gravity.


One continues:

  • But on this scale, voluntary causes are non-extant;
  • Therefore Geocentrism is an illusion.


The other continues:

  • But Geocentrism is what we directly observe;
  • Therefore causes that have will do exist and have power on this scale, like God and angels.


I know what an Atheist would chose. Given I'm Christian, can you guess what I would chose?*




* Jason Kendall should still be alive. He posted a video 10 days ago.




16:48 Tycho Brahe died in 1601.

His system was updated by Riccioli and was advanced against Galileo in the debate over his Assayer. St. Robert Bellarmine didn't bother to try to defend Ptolemy as such.

The update by Riccioli took into account Kepler's view on orbits being bifocal ellipses, not monocentric circles.

Now Riccioli's work was 17th C, Almagestum Novum came out in 1651.

17:32 As far as I can recall, "Almagest" is a corruption of "he megale syntaxis" just as "Istanbul" is of "eis ten polin" ...

Other video:

The Dawning of Astrophysics
Jason Kendall | 27 Dec. 2023
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-MfMGPppzg0


14:29 to past 14:39
instead of using circles he tried an ellipse so he said ah wait if I make the orbits not circular but ellipses guess what and put the Sun at the focus of one ellipse then it works


And if the ellipses are then later by Riccioli (after Kepler died) put back into Tycho Brahe's idea of Geoheliocentrism, it still works.

Rapture Theology and Date-Setting, NOT the Same Thing


Is The Rapture Biblical?
Marie Mazzanti | 12 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/HcyIJwhU6Yg


Let's be specific about the last point, shall we.

Day or hour is way more specific than "within a decade or two" ...

Now, a Catholic authoritative text, actually has connected the verse to date setting in the more general sense.

However, the text is in Lateran V, under Pope Leo X.

And the point to observe is, it comes in a disciplinary decree concerning preachers.

So, on that text, if I were ever appointed bishop or curate, or even certain types of deacon, I'd have a duty to avoid date setting. However, it doesn't specify laymen must have the exact same extra caution beyond Our Lord's words.

I totally agree on the post-Trib rapture, by the way, no Darby-fan here.




Never read or saw Left Behind.

Disagree on the character of "Nicolae Jetty Carpathia" (which doesn't add up to 666), there is no indication the Antichrist will sign a peace treaty.

However, I did read Mother Basilea Schlink. Lutheran nun, died in 2001. She wrote one book on angels, specifically guardian angels and one on the scary chapter of the Apocalypse (and she didn't teach a pre-Trib rapture).

Saturday, October 17, 2026

Reunion of Israel and Judah, Fulfilled 2000 Years Ago, Nearly


Israel and Judah Were Reunited in Christ, Not in 1948 (Ezekiel's Two Sticks)
Christ The King | 15 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eng8Ez1YHwU


1:07 Unless the Church as such restored them.

Christian Palestinians to this day are fruits of this reunited Kingdom, in the correct covenant, or for EO and Copts, a version of it.

3:30 And David ruled over Samaria at the well of Sychar and in Acts 8.

9:46 It can however be a population which for 2000 years has been at peace between North and South, between Kana and Samaria, Jerusalem and Bethlehem, and for the same time unarmed, fulfilling some peace prophecies about precisely Ephraim and Judah.

Jews to their detriment conflate this prophecy or these prophecies, which are fulfilled in the Christian Palestinian population, with the more universal prophecy of "the word of the Lord shall go out to the nations, commanding peace" which doesn't state this word would be obeyed at all or even most times by all. However, between Judah and Ephraim, the prophecy says actual disarmament.

Fulfilled in Christian Palestinians. (Al Qassem brigades are Muslim Palestinians, not Christian ones).

17:14 Both have been restored as the two first dioceses of the Catholic Church.

17:30 Historical evidence.

I happen to have read more history of the region than most, between Jesus' time and ours.

AD 70 to 313. The ethnically Jewish Church of Jerusalem fled to Pella (al Fahl in Jordan) and then returned after the legions left.

That's part of how St. Helen could find the Holy Cross, the Church recalled the locality of Calvary.

Chapter 1, I think, of Stephan Borgehammar's How the Holy Cross was Found: from event to Medieval legend.

AD 313 to Omar.

Chosroes invaded. He persecuted Christians and favoured Judaism. Many Christians "returned to the Judaism of their fathers" (the wording of the Anglican author, Derwas J. Chitty), implying they were of Jewish ethnicity.

Omar invaded. Some Beduin tribes (so Semitic populations) went to their monastery and told them "we were forced to convert, we are now Muslims, we are still your friends" implying Muslim Palestinians have ancestry in this Christian Palestinian (or possibly Negev Beduin) population.

Last chapter of The Desert a City by Derwas James Chitty. Previous ones were on Egyptian monasticism, this last one on Palestinian monasticism.

Archaeology. During my "excursion" to Orthodoxy (I'm a convert from Lutheranism in 1988, revert from Orthodoxy in 2009), I met a priest's or deacon's daughter or granddaughter, who had been at an archaeology dig of a monastery from this period, halted by Zionists. She displayed an Aramaic Our Father as found there.

Omar to present day. Both Christian Palestinians and Jews have been put under pressure to become Muslims and are thus roots of the Muslim Palestinian population.

Genetics. An iron age skeleton from Galilee has been compared to modern populations.

1) Closest match: Samaritans.
2nd closest: Christian Palestinians
12th to 15th closest: Muslim Palestinians
3rd to 11th or 3rd to 14th) between these last ones several populations of Mitsrahi Jews and also two populations of Druz.

She underdoes [understates] the case for Catholicism


Was the Reformation a Return to Biblical Christianity?
Humbled Catholic | 14 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUl9uK6-lNw


Before I hear your answer, no.

Matthew 28:16—20.

The passage means Jesus built his Church on Apostles (verse 16 tells us whom He's talking to), what their mission is (all truth and all justice), what their help is and for how long (Jesus Himself and every single day to the end of time), what His power is (all power in Heaven and on Earth) ...

This being so, there can be no "return to Biblical Christianity" ever, except individually or regionally or otherwise less than universally. Because it can never be universally lost.

The only Protestants who get this right are those supporting Baptist Continuity, and they don't claim the Reformation was a "return to Biblical Christianity" but rather an attempted and botched return to it under influence of Baptists who had never left it.

What these guys get wrong is Matthew 5:14—15. The continuing Church cannot be a hidden secret society.

1:53 Calvin actually was somewhat insincere (or very obtuse) about Matthew 28:20.

In his commentary, he states that the promise doesn't mean Jesus ties Himself like a mercenary to all supposed successors who might change His doctrine, but he doesn't even adress the question where (if not in the Catholic Church) the doctrine hadn't been misrepresented.

2:08 "the Church is always in need of purification and reform"

The Church Universal?

2:16 not every action of every Catholic

No, but every doctrine held by the Church Universal. I don't defend (at least not actively) the expulsion of Jews from Spain, but I do defend the expulsion of Jews with exceptions by St. Pius V, or the expulsion of Jewish usurers by St. Lewis IX of France.

7:01 Actually, some shall we say "thoughtful" Protestants actually agree with you about Tradition in the First Century, they just say that past then, the only remaining infallible authority is Scripture.

Obviously, this contradicts Matthew 28:16—20.

But at least it admits that Jesus didn't establish Sola Scriptura as such.

Nero Turtle Made Two Videos Recently


First Video:

Catholicism disregards Scripture.. ‪@anamunley‬
Nero Turtle | 13 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bv2-8I64cHc


My first reply is in this dialogue:

Mark Anthony
@Searchformeaningalways
As a former devout Roman Catholic, for any person and/or organization to declare that a human being is uncategorically in heaven, is pure HUBRIS.

Nero Turtle
@NeroTurtle
the bible is very clear that we do not know the hearts of men. And although outwardly they may have been and done great for the kingdom, we do not know their motives. Canonization is anti biblical. 100%

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@hglundahl
@NeroTurtle "we do not know the hearts of men."

That's why we don't canonise living persons.

"Canonization is anti biblical. 100%"

And Jesus said to him: Amen I say to thee, this day thou shalt be with me in paradise.
Luke 23:43


Some Catholics have claimed this was the first canonisation. I would say this was the first New Covenant canonisation — or the last Old Covenant one.

Previous Old Covenant ones include:

But for David's sake the Lord his God gave him a lamp in Jerusalem, to set up his son after him, and to establish Jerusalem Because David had done that which was right in the eyes of the Lord, and had not turned aside from any thing that he commanded him, all the days of his life, except the matter of Urias the Hethite
3 Kings (1 Kings) 15:4-5


We do not see a man's heart. God does. And God can respond about it, like for Hagiographers and prophets about King David, like at the Crucifixion about St. Dismas, or by working miracles on behalf of a deceased saint, as per canonisations in more recent times, after the canonic books were all written.

If the Catholic Church cannot even humanly speaking recognise a miracle, how come Biblical authors could?

Claiming Moses couldn't know if he had parted the Red Sea, as a human, but somehow he still could know so as hagiographer and Israelites only knew they had walked through the Red Sea by accepting the account of the Exodus, not from memory, well, that makes simply no sense at all.

Oh, Biblical proof that miracles are endorsements of people:

So that even there were brought from his body to the sick, handkerchiefs and aprons, and the diseases departed from them, and the wicked spirits went out of them.
Acts of Apostles 19:12


Nero Turtle
@hglundahl "That's why we don't canonise living persons." So... we don't know living people hearts, but we not dead people hearts. totally makes sense. I don't care how they "appeared to live". You can not judge what the motive may have been for any action they did dead or alive in any situation. You are not inside their brain. People do good things for selfish reasons all the time. Even in the religious realm.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@NeroTurtle The differences are two.

1) Wicked people tend to die wicked deaths, and good people edifying deaths.

By the time they die, there is usually some witness to their death. Before, not so often.

2) If God makes a miracle for a living person, it could be for something else than his person, or he could be good at the time and lose his salvation later.

If God makes a miracle for one having died, God is basically endorsing this person.

A selfish reason is not necessarily a bad reason. Selfishness is not the root of all evil, nor is all selfishness evil. We aren't celebrating saints for being complete altruists, but for loving God, and for seeing, in the miracles, especially after their death, God loving them back.


1:20 Apocalypse 6:9—11 doesn't use the term "saints", but clearly describes a category which is the most popular usage of "saints" in the Catholic Church.

The body of believers are, as Saint Paul uses it, collectively speaking saints. This doesn't guarantee that each individual in this collective is a saint.

If your sole beef with Catholicism is we use a different terminology, can you show beyond reasonable doubt that Biblical usage never varies in terminology for any concept?

Other example, St. Paul probably says "episkopoi" for what we call "priests" (presbyteroi), and for what we call diocesan bishops, he probably said "teachers" ... while he had other terms for other categories of bishops, including in his time still apostles (not limited to the twelve, btw).

Nero Turtle
We have a different perspective on death. I am of the camp called "sou sleep" and can use Revelation 6 alongside much of the rest of the bible to establish my view. For example, you can not use merely one verse to establish a doctrine. Regardless, you agree with my point in the second sentence in that alive people are saints. Thus the idea of become a saint only after death is not biblical. I have a lot of "beef" with Catholicism. As a protestant, there are three camps of eschatology. I am a historicist. In this camp, Catholicism (the system) is the first beast. The pope in history as a figure through all time (not a person in the future) is the anti-christ. Rather than writing a novel and in turn reading a novel... I recommend you watch the lecture series called Historicism made Easy on my playlists. It is a 37 video lecture series that covers the protestant reformation, historical continuity that establishes that timeline of the prophecies of Daniel, and more. Much of the material on the series actually comes from the Vatical Digital Library of all places. Just a snippet... the anti-christ will think to change times and laws. Publications like The Convert's Catechism of Catholic Doctrine by Rev. Peter Geiermann and historical extracts like The Catholic Mirror (1894) used colloquial or hyperbolic phrasing—stating that the Church transferred the solemnity or authority of the day. We also have (CCC 2190–2191): Clarifies that the Sabbath has not been "moved" by a later human decree, but rather replaced by Sunday to recall the new creation inaugurated by Christ's Resurrection. Not to mention we are on the using the Gregorian calendar after pope Gregory. I could type a book. I just suggest you watch the playlist. If you skip around you are missing out, because there is physical material evidences for my belief. Not just philosophical ones.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@NeroTurtle "Thus the idea of become a saint only after death is not biblical."

It's also not Catholic.

As mentioned, "saint" doesn't mean quite the same thing in both contexts.

You want a second verse for saints in Heaven ruling with Christ? You are a preterist, right? Or is historicist very different?

I'll give you two:

Blessed and holy is he that hath part in the first resurrection. In these the second death hath no power; but they shall be priests of God and of Christ; and shall reign with him a thousand years
[Apocalypse (Revelation) 20:6]


With the first resurrection not being a bodily one 1000 years in advance of goats and sheep judgement, but a spiritual by regeneration from sin, this means the saints are reigning with Christ. I e interceding for us.

The second death, i e damnation having no power means they are already safe and cannot be damned, this means they have died.

One more, given by St. Jerome:

These are they who were not defiled with women: for they are virgins. These follow the Lamb whithersoever he goeth. These were purchased from among men, the firstfruits to God and to the Lamb:
[Apocalypse (Revelation) 14:4]


So, if Jesus come to me, hearing me, they come to me as well, and I can adress them, or if I know someone to be among them, I can adress him.

Soul sleep ... a certain Mark Eugenicus of Ephesus, refusing to sign the council of Florence, actually taught soul sleep while denying Purgatory. He didn't deny prayers for the dead and also not prayers by the ones in blessed soulsleep awaiting a blessed resurrection.

As to the martyrs under the altar resting, it's not incompatible with them speaking and therefore doesn't teach soul sleep, at least not an uninterrupted one.

@NeroTurtle "In this camp, Catholicism (the system) is the first beast."

If the problem is having a different week from Old Covenant Jews, do you require Christians to use the Hebrew calendar too?

Even if Hillel II changed it from one observed to a pre-calculated?

I think I'll post this question under your historicism video though ...

@NeroTurtle wait, the historicism video you link to isn't yours and it also doesn't allow comments ....

Nero Turtle
@hglundahl so... please explain why that matters at all. I am giving it out as a resource. Feel free to use that as an excuse if you like. It is whatever.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@NeroTurtle I was intending to answer you under that one, which doesn't seem possible.

Nero Turtle
@hglundahl how can you answer me under over 45 hours of material regardless. It covers so much history, were you panning to write a dissertation on each video? 1 Thes. 5;21. Prove all things and hold fast to that which is good. Feel free to spend the time learning something new with physical historical evidence. Or not. Your call.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@NeroTurtle I am a debater, for instance with you, as long as you like.

I am not your and even less Walter Veith's student.

The Sunday Visitor, the Converts' Catechism, they are publications which have approval of local Catholic authorities, they are not the voice of the Church universal.

Oh, ideally the Catechism should contain no error, but if it contains a minor error of fact, that doesn't disqualify it as an error. I'm talking about the Convert's Catechism, which is a Catholic one.

CCC is by the Vatican II Sect. It is also for those mistaking it as Catholicism way more official.

So, pointing to such a minor publication as a Catholic newspaper or a Convert's Catechism as "the Catholic Church admits" is an error of method.

Both the journalist of the one and the author of the other were American people, native or by immigration, caught up in a conversation taking place in the US of A. As such they felt a pressure to provide certain answers and can have answered certain questions badly.


2:52 As said, "only God knows the heart of a man" applies prior to God deciding to reveal sth about it.

Miracles are His preferred way of doing such revelation, as per Biblical ones.

Nero Turtle
show me in scripture where doing a miracle vindicated if that person would make it to heaven later. Obviously, we would both agree that people like Arron and Moses are on the team and they did that cool snake thing and such. However, show me in scripture that doing a miracle vindicates your salvific status.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@NeroTurtle "show me in scripture where doing a miracle vindicated if that person would make it to heaven later."

No where at all.

Judas did miracles and the guys who Jesus talks to with "I never knew you" at least were practising exorcists (which is a specific office in the Catholic Church, no more guarantees you will make it to Heaven than giving a valid absolution or celebrating a valid mass, even greater miracles).

That's why post mortem miracles are important.

Jesus didn't say "I never knew you" to people saying "did you not wake up dead from our bones?" as with Elisha / Eliseus or with St. Martin of Tours.

Nero Turtle
@hglundahl you are a claim from, (in my opinion), what is called an argument for ignorance. Latin: argumentum ad ignorantiam. Your claim is not evidence from scripture, otherwise you would have quoted it. A lack of evidence is not evidence of absence. Just because something has not been proven yet does not mean the opposite is automatically true. The Muslims use this tactic to argue that Jesus is not God. Jesus did not say "X", thus.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@NeroTurtle We have a tit for tat.

YOU want me to show where in Scripture someone doing miracles while alive is guaranteed salvation later on when he dies.

I answer nowhere, and equally, nowhere is someone doing miracles after his death NOT endorsed.

Now, I want YOU to admit that instead of pretending I made a less significant argument than you, AND to admit which of these is more significant in relation to the Catholic custom to look for miracles of a deceased person after he passed.

Nero Turtle
@hglundahl No. You are misunderstanding me. The Catholicism claim, to my understanding on canonization it to in part look at the miracles to help justification of that persons relation ship with God (aka; salvation status). I am merely requestion a scriptural vindication of this concept.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@NeroTurtle The scriptural example is Elisha.

Now, your objection is damned people getting damned after working miracles.

The answer to that one is, Elisha is not damned, he did miracles after dying.

Those damned people as far as we are told didn't.


3:29 The "I never knew you" passage involves people doing miracles while alive and being endorsed by God for something other than their persons.

When God does a miracle on behalf of someone already deceased, it's either not quite complete as a miracle, or it's an endorsement of the person.

And some that were burying a man, saw the rovers, and cast the body into the sepulchre of Eliseus. And when it had touched the bones of Eliseus, the man came to life, and stood upon his feet
4 Kings (2 Kings) 13:21


Nero Turtle
I am very aware about the verse on the person being healed by the bones. Beyond that you made a few claims. I look forward to scriptural validation on both of them.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@NeroTurtle I think you'd agree that God validated Eliseus before IV Kings (or you might call it II Kings) was completed and a hagiographer did so.

I also think you would agree that the raising of one dead with Elisha or three dead with St. Martin of Tours is a very complete miracle.

My observation on incomplete ones is hedging. Not a primary claim of Catholicism, but hedging.


Second Video:

Catholicism's interpretation of sacred Scripture.. ‪@TotusCatholicaEN‬
Nero Turtle | 17 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IT7UbbQZiWY


Nero Turtle
[pinned comment,
original text]
Root word: βατταλογήσητε - vein repetition. Catholicism tends to argue that older is better. But only when it suits the agenda. The lexicon conclusion for this matter was established in 1611. But they prefer the 1960 version.

[pinned comment,
changed text]
Root word: βατταλογήσητε - vein repetition. Catholicism prefers to confirm their faith from a copy of a copy. Rather than directly from the Hebrew and Greek. (edited because a Catholic commenter corrected me on my points regarding dates. I am okay admitting I was wrong.)

Hans-Georg Lundahl
The lexicon conclusion was a minority opinion by scholars from Geneva and later England.

Exactly three old Bible translations have this: Geneva Bible, Bishops' Bible, King James.

Douay Rheims is earlier than King James and has:

And when you are praying, speak not much, as the heathens. For they think that in their much speaking they may be heard
Matthew 6:7


Now, this repeats the way St. Jerome dealt with it, by rephasing. However Coptic and Syriac translations actually do give a translation "don't stutter" ...

EXACTLY what human type of discourse can be described both as stuttering and as using many words? Explaining yourself to someone above you, and don't completely trust, and being nervous.

This is exactly what Velleius Paterculus did in the last chapter (paragraph we would say) of his Roman History book II. Not by repetitive insisting on a phrase, but by constant rephrasing, from one deity to the next, hedging the petitions, giving each "a reason" to hear the prayer.

Now, "older is better" doesn't mean a Renaissance scholar or an Enlightenment scholar is better at history or linguistics than someone after 19th C.

1:23 I'm sorry, you are susbtituting Calvin's pseudo-scholarship and its English endorsement for the actual Greek.

As I recall, saying something over and over again actually has a known Greek term, it's thrallein.

Nero Turtle
The Douay-Rheims was a translation of a translation. It was translated from the Latin Vulgate. I think you and I have talked on that before already. Good note on the dates though. I will change the pinned comment since you are correct on the dates.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@NeroTurtle Did you totally skip my second comment and did you only read the first lines of my first one? There is a button "see more" and when people miss that, I speak of "Seymour syndrome" ...

Now, to your changed text:

"Catholicism prefers to confirm their faith from a copy of a copy. Rather than directly from the Hebrew and Greek. (edited because a Catholic commenter corrected me on my points regarding dates. I am okay admitting I was wrong.)"

You missed the Syriac and Coptic BOTH giving a real translation of battalogein rather than rephrasing, and BOTH translating "stuttering" ... you also missed that repeating a phrase over and over again is "thrallein" in Greek.

Greco-Roman pagans didn't have repetitive prayers, but they did have prayers that come across like Edmund stuttering to the White Witch ... starting over and over again, not of a will to persist, but of a fear of having missed the right formula. Velleius Paterculus' last preserved paragraph is an example.


2:00 "between sacred and forgotten"

Not sure where the Catholicism is that he's describing, there are lots of Catholic places where praying the Rosary (including the Hail Mary's over and over again) is very commonplace.

Thursday, October 15, 2026

Some of This Gets Personal, But I Don't Neglect Rational Inquiry for Navel Gazing ... (Features Fatima)


How Catholics Know if it's a Miracle
Brian Holdsworth | 15 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vlpjRtmSJhU


Re beginning.

I have not stated I'm a prophet, so I don't need to prove it by miracle. The only proof I have to provide as a debater is rational argument.

If any "Catholic" has taken my writings under the scrutiny "real or false prophet?" that's abusive.

Not saying someone necessarily has, but that would kind of explain the "radio silence" ... something that could have been imposed for the sake of such a test.

There are other reasons I could think of, at least one of them worse.

6:17 Angels and demons can move objects by their act of will, not totally unlike how the human soul does with the human body, but the higher spirits aren't inherently tied to a specific material object.

Technology can move objects by the physical effects of other objects, which are ultimately moved by what a man's body can move moved by man's will.

I can turn a switch or hit letters on a keyboard, then technology produces the light in the room or the letters in your comment section.

10:27 Alas, my beginning relief from lice on death date and burial (deposition) date of Charlie Kirk do not meet the criterium sudden and inexplicable.

There still are some ...

10:57 Angelic beings do have the power to move celestial objects.

However, a demon couldn't actually move the Sun, because an angel in grace with God is moving it.

That said, there are Catholics who have claimed the thing happening didn't happen up at the level of the Sun at all ...

I think Dom Stanley Jaki OSB made such a point and also pretended this applied to Joshua's long day.

11:16 Illusions are not always through states of mind.

A physical appearance of something happening is, given demons can move objects and manipulate light, per se possible.

11:33 If a demon alters what's visible from below the atmosphere, from the ground, the demon doesn't need to have access to the minds.

Note, I'm a Fatima defender, but I don't feel we need to overdo what's impossible to demons.

Because God won't produce a miracle for someone if it won't help them in their faith.


I'm sorry, but God can produce miracles for one person to benefit the faith of someone else.

13:46 If they had stronger evidence of Catholicism being bad than the miracle is of it being good, that would not be circular reasoning.

They don't have that, in actual fact, but it would be a "breaking of the circle" as such arguments are "healed" ...

Friday, October 9, 2026

Let's not be Noahides, Shan't we!


Caleb Flynn's Inlaws "We Forgive You"
Allie Beth Stuckey | ? October 2026
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/o1VL4SDzHx4


The government has a responsibility to execute murderers?

Bible or Noahide "laws"?

Romans 13 speaks of "the prince" who was an heir of Julius Caesar, and those ended in 1918 when Charles the Last left Hofburg.

Even very vile murders can be forgiven not just on the moral, but also on the penal plane.

Stabbing a younger girl you are impatient to seduce while she resists you and doing so 14 times giving her 24 more hours to live on earth is a very vile murder.

Alessandro Serenelli was forgiven by the mother, and not least by the victim herself, St. Maria Goretti. While she was dying and after confessing, she was worried he would go to Hell, and told, not necessarily, not if you forgive him and pray for him.

She spent her last 24 hours praying for her murderer and in prison he converted. Sentenced to 30 years, he did 27. When he came out, Assunta Goretti, the mother, forgave him.




Genesis 9? Eisegesis.

For I will require the blood of your lives at the hand of every beast, and at the hand of man, at the hand of every man, and of his brother, will I require the life of man Whosoever shall shed man's blood, his blood shall be shed: for man was made to the image of God
[Genesis 9:5-6]


God says "I will require" and not "you shall require".

He also says "shall be shed" and not "ye shall shed".




Haydock commentary on above verses:

Ver. 5. At the hand; a Hebrew idiom. God orders an ox to be stoned, which had slain a man, Exodus xxi. 28. --- Man, (hominis) every man, (viri) brother. By these three terms, God inculcates a horror of bloodshed; because we are all of the same nature, ought to act like generous men, and to consider every individual as a brother, since we spring from the same stock. (Menochius)

Ver. 6. Shed. God had not subjected Cain to this law of retaliation, as he was the first murderer, and the earth was unpeopled. (Haydock) --- Here he declares, that it is just to inflict such a punishment on the offender. (Menochius) --- Judges are hence authorized to punish murderers with death. (Calmet) --- The general law, thou shalt not kill, admits of exceptions, and forbids killing by private authority, or out of revenge. (Haydock) --- The blood of your lives, may signify the blood on which your life depends; or, according to the Rabbin, it is a prohibition of suicide, which one would think is so contrary to the first law of nature, self-preservation, as to require no prohibition; and yet, to the scandal of philosophers, some have written in its defence! (Haydock)


So, the commentary does not say that the retaliation by death penalty allows no exceptions, and mentions one exception with a somewhat sloppy explanation. Cain. By close to 130 or 230 years after Adam's creation, earth was not so unpeopled that there were not a sufficient number capable of killing him in return. However, all of them were close blood relatives, like "unpeopled" also being the reason Cain and Seth could marry sisters. But if God made an exception for avoiding another kinslaying, God can make and allow more exceptions. Menochius says capital punishment is just, not that it's always the only possible justice.

Sunday, October 4, 2026

Larry Alex Taunton Imagines He Knows What Fascism is Better than I, and Confuses it with National Socialism, like an East European!


What Is Fascism? The Definition They Won't Teach You
Larry Alex Taunton | 3 Oct. 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Km7o6zZV5UE


Which is the Fascism you want defined?

Italian Fascism or the movement in large?

I hope you are not both enlarging it to include National Socialism and then narrowing it so as to make everything else if not outside at least irrelevant.

Italian Fascism was different things to different people. What Pius XI approved as a legitimate régime in 1929 was Fascism and what he condemned in Non abbiamo bisogno is also Fascism ... at least became elevanted by Il Duce to that after that encyclical, at the time it was an Education Minister's opinion on Fascism.

The general movement has more to do with what Pius XI approved.

1) Corporatismo (Italian sense, look it up, don't confuse with US usage of "corporations") is good in the case of a society divided into workers and employers for a large part of the population.
2) Dictatorship is at least licit as a form of government.
3) Abortion is banned, at least excepting the saving of a mother's life.

I agree with all three. I think Austro-Fascism and Franco express some aspects in a more Catholic way, but the Italian version for a time had some record of humane dealings with opposition and with punishment.

You are aware that Alessandro Serenelli was released on parole under Mussolini? He was not required to enter a monastery from the side of authorities, and he had lived on good terms with the victim's mother prior to that.

Crime, 1902. Sentence, 30 years. One year off for all, at WW-I victory for Italy (one in which the future Duce participated at the expense of my dear Austria, you know Southern Tyrolia). Two more years off for good behaviour. 27 years. 1902 + 27 = 1929. The year Il Duce and the Pope signed the Vatican treaty.

I

justspazzin 64
@justspazzin64
Codsweallop. Fascism was BORN out of socialism. Socialism is LEFT-WING. Mussolini was a member of the Italian communist party. This is not rocket science.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@hglundahl
@justspazzin64 You are not a rocket scientist, I suppose.

You are not a historian, I know for certain.

Mussolini was a top member of the Italian Socialist Party, according to his own wikipedia, which links to PSI (Partito Socialista d'Italia), which says:

The Italian Socialist Party (Italian: Partito Socialista Italiano, PSI) was a social democratic and democratic socialist political party in Italy


This was in 1912. Both Fascists and Communists are split offs from this party, but different ones. In 1911 Mussolini to his great honour had protested against Italy's war in Libya which featured the first bombing from air planes, carried out against civilians. In 1913, Mussolini, while rooting for Marx, also rooted for John Hus (Giovanni Hus il veredico is a work of his from this time).

Now, Franco never was member of a Communist or Socialist party. Neither was Salazar. Neither was Dollfuss. Neither was Schuschnigg. THEIR common ground with Mussolini came from Catholic social teaching, not from Marx. A precursor of Franco in Spain, the gang leader José Antonio Primo de Rivera, considered Marx a "talented Jew, who saw the problem of Capitalism, but not the solution ..." (to Capitalism / to this problem).

I noted as a first question to the video whether Larry meant Italian Fascism or whether he meant Fascism as a more general movement. And found to my chagrin, he was so inept he extended Fascism all the way to Hitler (who actually was a Communist comrade of Eisner in the Munich Soviet) and then defined Fascism in general from Hitler, perhaps not surprising since he went to Berlin to study the subject and Berliners are so guiltridden for Hitler that they don't even clearly perceive any other Fascism except in a Hitler haze.

justspazzin 64
@hglundahl Mussolini was a member of the Italian Communist/socialist party who both founded the doctrine of fascism and coined the term. It's just a simple fact. Hence fascism was born out of socialism. Socialism is left-wing, not right wing.

@hglundahl "You are not a rocket scientist, I suppose."

Nope, and nowhere claimed to be a rocket scientist. And it's a good thing you don't need to be a "rocket scientist" to understand the SOCIALIST origin of fascism.

"You are not a historian, I know for certain."

Define "historian." Are you engaging in an appeal to authority logical fallacy?

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@justspazzin64 " the Italian Communist/socialist party"

Are two different ones.

I'm saying "you are not a historian" as an euphemism for "you are egregiously wrong on history". You are not a mathematician if you think "2 + 2 = 5"

"who both founded the doctrine of fascism"

No. If you mean the Sansepolcro programme, 1919, yes, he founded it, but didn't stay with it.

If you meant the book he wrote "on the topic," most of it was a rehash of an older book by Gentile, who was a Hegelian.

In 1931 or so*, Pius XI condemned that doctrine, but could as yet not call it Fascism, because it was Gentile's opinion of Fascism and only functioned where Gentile had authority, as minister of Education.

I condemn it too.

This book is absolutely not the founding of Austrofascism, where you should instead go to the Catholic priest Mgr Seipel, both Volk, Staat, Nation and Wirtschaftsethische Lehre der Kirchenväter.

AND Quadregesimo Anno by Pope Pius XI.**

Spanish and Portuguese Fascism are also not founded by Mussolini or Gentile.

* footnote:
June 29, 1931, to be precise. NON ABBIAMO BISOGNO

** footnote:
Signed the fifteenth day of May, in the year 1931, QUADRAGESIMO ANNO

justspazzin 64
@hglundahl "" the Italian Communist/socialist party"

Are two different ones."

Socialism is communism lite ...soft communism. That is the only discernable difference. Socialism is left-wing.

"Democracy is indispensable to socialism." -Vladimir Lenin.

"Communism needs democracy like the human body needs oxygen." -Leon Trotsky.

"The goal of socialism is communism." -Vladimir Lenin.

"Whoever wants to reach socialism by any other path than that of political democracy will inevitably arrive at conclusions that are absurd and reactionary both in the economic and the political sense." -Vladimir Lenin.

"Social democracy is objectively the moderate wing of fascism.... These organisations (i.e. fascism and social democracy) are not antipodes, they are twins." --Joseph Stalin.

@hglundahl "you are egregiously wrong on history".

Codswallop.

@hglundahl My claim that fascism was BORN out of socialism, that socialism is LEFT-WING, and that Mussolini who founded the ideology of fascism was a member of the Italian socialist/communist party ...all still stand as fact.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@justspazzin64 The one you cited who was moderately correct was Stalin.

Fascism, National Socialism, Social Democracy are related.

Social Democracy had Eugenics in Scandinavia, like National Socialism up to 1945. Social Democracy has abortion, like Communism.

Fascism as such had neither that kind of eugenics (just pro-natal policies, which are good) and also not abortion.

Fascism didn't produce any Holodomor or Irish "Potato Famine" unlike Communism or Capitalism.

delay
justspazzin64 has answered, but also on below thread, I privileged the below one, since it included the Irish "Potato Famine" ... will see if I can answer him tomorrow.

II

justspazzin64
"Which is the Fascism you want defined?

Italian Fascism or the movement in large?"


Mussolini the anti-capitalist is the sole source of fascism. There is no other source or definition of "fascism" except Mussolini's own description, period. The VERY first fascist movements emerged in Italy during World War I. Mussolini himself DEFINED "fascism."

According to Italian fascist dictator Benito Mussolini's own account, the Fasces of Revolutionary Action were founded in Italy in 1915. In 1919, Mussolini founded the Italian Fasces of Combat in Milan (Fasci di combattimento), which became the 'National Fascist Party' two years later. Fascism was born directly and exclusively out of left-wing socialism. Anyone who believes fascism is "right-wing" has been extensively lied to and brainwashed. By the mid-1930s, even Trotsky could insist that ‘Stalinism (communism) and fascism, in spite of deep difference in social foundations, are symmetrical phenomena’." Even Stalin himself claimed there was no real distinction between 'democracy' and fascism: "Social democracy is objectively the moderate wing of fascism.... These organisations (i.e. fascism and social democracy) are not antipodes, they are twins." --Joseph Stalin.

There’s No Denying the Socialist Roots of Fascism, Foundation for Economic Education, Emmanuel Rincףn, November 27, 2021:

"fascism is a form of socialism. As such, it does not engage in a fight between left and right, but between different leftists ideologies. ...

...Giovanni Gentile, a neo-Hegelian philosopher, was the intellectual author of the “doctrine of fascism,” which he wrote in conjunction with Benito Mussolini. Gentile’s sources of inspiration were thinkers such as Hegel, Nietzsche, and also Karl Marx. ...

Gentile went so far as to declare “Fascism is a form of socialism, in fact, it is its most viable form.” One of the most common reflections on this is that fascism is itself socialism based on national identity.

Gentile believed that all private action should be oriented to serve society. He was against individualism, for him there was no distinction between private and public interest. In his economic postulates, he defended compulsory state corporatism, wanting to impose an autarkic state (basically the same recipe that Hitler would use years later)."

The Two Faces of Janus: Marxism and Fascism in the Twentieth Century, A. James Gregor, Hoover Institution, Arnold Beichman, August 1, 2000:

"Recalling that Mussolini began his political career as a distinguished Italian socialist, Gregor writes: "Fascism’s most direct ideological inspiration came from the collateral influence of Italy’s most radical ‘subversives’ — the Marxists of revolutionary syndicalism."

Even Nikolai Bukharin, the leading Soviet ideologist whom Stalin purged, began to have misgivings about the Revolution and began to allude to the fascist features of the emerging system. Gregor writes: 'By the early 1930s, the ‘convergence’ of fascism and Stalinism struck Marxists and non-Marxists alike. . . .

By the mid-1930s, even Trotsky could insist that ‘Stalinism and fascism, in spite of deep difference in social foundations, are symmetrical phenomena' ..."

-------------------------
The Socialist Roots of Fascism: The Case Against Socialism, Case For Conservatism, Ryan Wiseman, 27 August 2024:

"In fact, as part of his [Mussolini's] strategy to propagandize and push fascism, he wrote a book, Fascism: Doctrine and Institutions. Among the other leftist things he said in the book, he wrote that “The Fascist conception of life stresses the importance of the State and accepts the individual only in so far as his interests coincide with the State. . . . It is opposed to classical liberalism . . . [which] denied the State in the name of the individual. ...

...And it goes on. One of the propagandists for Italian fascism was an apologist by the name of Fausto Pitigliani. He said: “The function of private enterprise is assessed from the standpoint of public interest, and hence an owner or director of a business undertaking is responsible before the State for his production policy.” In other words, once again, businesses and industries weren’t free to determine their own directions in order to best meet their customers’ needs, but instead the elite that ran the state controlled what direction a business would take, based on their own ideas of what the public interest was."

-----------------
Yes, They Were Socialists: How the Nazis Waged War on Private Property, Mises Institute, John Kennedy, 07/05/2022:

"How did the National Socialists combat private property in Germany? The first step came shortly after the Nazis took control, when they abolished private property. Article 153 of the Weimar constitution guaranteed private property, with expropriation only to occur within the due process of the law, but this article was nullified by a decree on February 28, 1933.

With this, the new National Socialist government had complete control of private property in Germany. While they did not take complete control of the lands like the Bolsheviks did in Russia in 1917, the Nazis issued quotas for industries and farms, and later they reorganized all industry into corporations run by members of the Nazi Party. ...

Conclusion
The Nazi government took control of the economy, which is what one expects from socialism."

--------------------
The Socialist Roots of Fascism, UK Dispatch, LB
Aug 12, 2025:

"The truth, however, is that socialism is not anti fascist at all. On the contrary, fascism has always been a form of socialism.

Benito Mussolini, the architect of fascism, used socialism as a foundation to create fascism. In his book, Fascism: Doctrine and Institutions, Mussolini wrote that “The Fascist conception of life stresses the importance of the State and accepts the individual only in so far as his interests coincide with the State. . . It is opposed to classical liberalism . . . (which) denied the State in the name of the individual.”

The National Socialism used by fascists like Mussolini allowed private business to survive as long as it was directed by government subsidies and policy, a form of socialist control more commonly known as “crony capitalism,” where government rewards its political friends rather than allowing the operation of a free market.”

Similar to Marx in “The Communist Manifesto,” in his 1928 autobiography, Mussolini bemoaned liberal capitalism, stating that “The citizen in the Fascist State is no longer a selfish individual who has the anti-social right of rebelling against any law of the Collectivity.”

Later on, in a 1945 speech in Milan, six days before his death, Mussolini described his fascist movement as follows: “In this case, there can be no doubt: we are the working class in struggle for life and death, against capitalism. We are the revolutionaries in search of a new order. If this is so, to invoke help from the bourgeoisie by waving the red peril is an absurdity.”

------------------------
“If there is one thing all Fascists and National Socialists agreed on, it was their hostility to capitalism.” —Eugen Weber, historian of fascism.

Hans Georg Lundahl
@justspazzin64 Christianity is not favourable to Capitalism either.

You call out Communism or Socialism for the Holodomor?

I'd go with Communism. Capitalism committed a very similar crime in 1847 to 1853 on Ireland.

People didn't starve because no one grew anything else than potatoes.

Everyone who grew potatoes for himself grew wheat for his landlord.

And in that time, landlords stood on the contract. Tenants needed wheat to survive? Too bad, not on the contract.

Potatoes was it.

When it came to giving relief, the government put that down to low levels, in order to keep what modern Capitalists would call "accountability" ...

Being hostile to Capitalism is not a sin, and Leo XIII called that out, indirectly, by reminding of the principle that man works to live and therefore has a right to wages amounting to decent livelihood. Rerum Novarum, if you want to look it up.*

You presumably cite three works because you can't reach the conclusion from the facts you know.

Minor quibbles, there is not just one ideology of Fascism and Mussolini didn't found all of them.

@justspazzin64 Some more quibbles.

You didn't cite even one history of Italy, for the period, not even one biography of Mussolini, but several analyses on the very ideological level, which are not necessarily the least selective or most objective.

On top of that, you cited Gentile, while obviously back in 1931 his ideology could not yet be solidly identified with Fascism. Which I already stated.

On top of that, you brought in National Socialism, which is a different ideology. But it's possible that Trotsky pioneered including that in Fascism.

* footnote
RERUM NOVARUM, May 15, 1891.

justspazzin 64
@hglundahl "Christianity is not favourable to Capitalism either. "

Blatantly false.

@hglundahl "Capitalism committed a very similar crime in 1847 to 1853 on Ireland.

Total codswallop! Capitalism had nothing to do with the Irish Potato Famine ...the very reason why my Welsh and Irish forefathers immigrated to America! The Irish Potato Famie (An Gorta Mór) was triggered by the potato blight, a "natural' disaster, which destroyed the staple crop of the rural poor, combined with Irish incompetence, not 'capitalism.'

@hglundahl "People didn't starve because no one grew anything else than potatoes."

Dead false! ...again!

@hglundahl "that man works to live and therefore has a right to wages amounting to decent livelihood."

Lol! Do tell, where in the Bible do the "decent livlihood" come in?

Fact is, the Bible does not explicitly endorse or condemn capitalism.

However, in moral principles by parables, the Bible DOES support capitalist precepts and principles like the Parable of the Talents in Matthew 25:14-30, and a similar parable in Luke 12: 42 and 19:11-27. In 2 Thessalonians 3:10 we are plainly told; " For even when we were with you, we commanded you this: If anyone will not work, neither shall he eat" ...which is anti-socialism as it gets!

Fact is socialism is inseparably and exclusively based on greed and covetousness of OTHER PEOPLES PROPERTY AND WEALTH! That is precisely why we are commanded you shall not steal and you shall not covet! And last but not least, the Bible nowhere condemns the ownership of wealth or property, both of which are anathema to socialism. There is no Biblical command to TAKE from the rich by force and give it to the poor! There is no Bible command to redistribute wealth BY FORCE. If it is by FORCE then it is NO LONGER free will charity!

All of the following Bible passages CLEARLY support capitalist principles and precepts:

“In the house of the wise are stores of choice food and oil, but a foolish man devours all he has.” – Proverbs 21:20.

“So if you have not been trustworthy in handling worldly wealth, who will trust you with true riches?” – Luke 16:11.

“Wealth gained hastily will dwindle, but whoever gathers little by little will increase it.” – Proverbs 13:11.

“A generous person will prosper; whoever refreshes others will be refreshed.” – Proverbs 11:25.

“Those who work their land will have abundant food, but those who chase fantasies have no sense.” – Proverbs 12:11.

“Whoever is kind to the poor lends to the Lord, and he will reward them for what they have done.” – Proverbs 19:17

“All hard work brings a profit, but mere talk leads only to poverty.” – Proverbs 14:23.

“Each of you should give what you have decided in your heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.” – 2 Corinthians 9:7.

“Anyone who has been stealing must steal no longer, but must work, doing something useful with their own hands, that they may have something to share with those in need.” – Ephesians 4:28.

Don’t collect any more than you are required to,” he told them. Then some soldiers asked him, “And what should we do?” He replied, “Don’t extort money and don’t accuse people falsely—be content with your pay.” – Luke 3:13-14.

“Be sure you know the condition of your flocks, give careful attention to your herds; for riches do not endure forever, and a crown is not secure for all generations.” – Proverbs 27:23-24.

“I am not saying this because I am in need, for I have learned to be content whatever the circumstances.” – Philippians 4:11.

“Keep falsehood and lies far from me; give me neither poverty nor riches, but give me only my daily bread. Otherwise, I may have too much and disown you and say, ‘Who is the Lord?’ Or I may become poor and steal, and so dishonor the name of my God.” – Proverbs 30:8-9.

“I was young and now I am old, yet I have never seen the righteous forsaken or their children begging bread.” – Psalms 37:25.

Tell me you are Biblically illiterate without telling me you are Biblically illiterate.

@hglundahl "You presumably cite three works because you can't reach the conclusion from the facts you know."

False! ...again!!

My "conclusion" (not PAY ATTENTION this time!) is that "Fascism was BORN out of socialism. Socialism is LEFT-WING. Mussolini was a member of the Italian communist party. This is not rocket science." ... JUST AS I HAVE ALREADY claimed, you blathering slow coach!

@hglundahl "Minor quibbles, there is not just one ideology of Fascism and Mussolini didn't found all of them."

False!... yet again! Mussolini was the SOLE author ...the SOLE "father"... of fascism. In 1919, Benito Mussolini, and no one else, founded the Italian Fascist Party FIRST. What others took from and made from Mussolini's doctrine of fascism is entirely irrelevant to, and does nothing to disprove, the simple fact that fascism was not only exclusively founded by Mussolini, but the very name "fascism" was coined exclusively by Mussolini. Get off the short bus already!

@hglundahl "You presumably cite three works because you can't reach the conclusion from the facts you know."

MORE blather and gibberish!

My* "CONCLUSION" was REACHED LONG AGO and I PLAINLY STATED MY "CONCLUSION" FROM the very beginning, EVEN BEFORE I "CITED" ANYONE!

I will post it for you again verbatim!!:

"Fascism was BORN out of socialism. Socialism is LEFT-WING. Mussolini was a member of the Italian communist party. This is not rocket science."

You are one hella slow coach, Gomer! Congrats!

* footnote
Is "justspazzin 64" an alias for Larry Alex Taunton? If it were just a listener, why did he reach the conclusion long ago?

Why is he so defensive on Larry's views?

Theoretically it could of course be someone less vocal whom Larry listened to before doing the speech, but I doubt it ...

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@justspazzin64 Apart from there being nothing in those passages of:

  • allowing the taking of interest
  • allowing any kind of masters to starve their workers to death


which are Capitalist excesses, you seem to be illiterate about 1847—53 Ireland and about 1920-22 Italy.

Potatoes were the staple food of the poor, yes, and let's be very precise. The poor didn't own their own land, as poor people in Kentucky have been went to do, they were tenants. The poor were tenants who grew potatoes for themselves and wheat for their landlords.

While these tenants were starving to death, or to expulsion as hunger made them to weak to work, the landlords were doing business as usual* with wheat that they had from the work of the same tenants who were starving or expelled.

From 1920 to 1922, Italian Communists, of whom Mussolini never was a member, tried to make a Revolution in Italy, involving expropriation of big to moderately small farms and small business. The people who defended ownership and employers remaining in charge were in black shirts and belonged to Fasci di combattimento.

In 1922, Mussolini marched on Rome. He took power. In 1926 he outlawed the Communist party which had been founded in 1921. This must not be confused with the Socialist party, of which he had been a member, and of which Matteotti was a member when he was killed (Matteotti's son claims the initiative didn't come from the Duce, but from the King, over a petrol affair).

@justspazzin64 The parable of the talents doesn't endorse taking interest. That practise is explicitly condemned elsewhere.

If anyone will not work doesn't specify having to prefer working under a master.

In some societies, free enterprise is an option even for some of the poor.

For my own part, I am working, and Capitalist prejudice denies me that and blacklists my attempts to get paid for my work by encouraging the founding of a publishing house. Invoking Thessalonians to "rebuke" me would be the height of hypocrisy, yet Capitalists will do that.

* footnote
see for instance:

Why didn't Irish people eat fish during the Great Famine
Irish History Podcast | 20 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=17RE_G-DJzg


Why Did the Catholic Church Stay Silent During the Irish Great Famine?
Irish History Podcast | 17 April 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LaKUqDbABtY


"In fascism, there is private property, but the private property is only a bit of an illusion because it's controlled by the state."

Wait, if the state can sue and heavily fine an employer for giving too low (or too high) wages, or for overworking the workers in hours, does that make "private property an illusion"?

If that's the case, private property has only existed since very recently even in the champions of it.

"there's usually a strong um anti-semitic element in fascism"

No antisemitism in Italy prior to 1938, and then it was basically, Jews converting to Catholicism can't marry ethnically Italian Jews.

1922 - 1942 = 20 years.
1938 - 1942 = 4 years.

No antisemitism in Portugal, meaning at all, under all the years of Salazar (1933 -- 1974).

No antisemitism in Spain, from 1939 to 1980 (formally the state type continued after Franco's death some years, by 1980 at least, Spain is Parlamentarian, though some resent it.

Both countries were countries of refuge for Jews under WW-II.

Some more antisemitism in the very marginal Integralismo of Brazil, which was never in power, and in Rexism, which was only in power as a puppet régime to Hitler. The same can be said of French Fascism as of Rexism.

The Swedish Fascist Engdahl, who was never in power directly, but claimed to have influenced Social Democracy through one who was member of both parties, took a very clear distance from Hitler after hearing of the camps, and his other remaining model apart from Il Duce, namely Perón, was not an antisemite either.

Did Larry Taunton learn his lore on fascism from some college conversation, or from the Marxist Umberto Eco's 14 points?

Austrofascism theoretically was antisemite, and didn't hurt Jews. He made some limitation on their, as on other ethnic minorities' rights to start new business (only if the extant ones were less than a certain percent of the branch). This was probably one of the reasons why Hitler hated Dollfuss and despised Schuschnigg. He also tortured Schuschnigg by psychiatric harrassment, after the Anschluss.

"Communism has always had a strong anti-semitic element and it may not be written into their you know into their you know equivalent to the Westminster confession But it's always it's always been there."

That's how they recruited Jews to Red Army officers and Cheka agents?

Stalin was antisemite, it was also he and Lysenko who rid Russian Communism of Eugenics, which Lenin had plotted on a research stage.

Austrian, Italian, Spanish and Portuguese Fascism, like Peronism, didn't have Eugenics unless you count pro-natalism and anti-abortion as that.

As in Italy, in Argentina the more extreme reproductive-social technologies associated with eugenics in northern Europe, especially sterilisation, met with considerable cultural, religious and political resistance, The eugenists within the Association followed the Catholic line from conviction and/or necessity. But since it was through women, or more precisely motherhood, that the future biotypological identity and health of the nation was seen to be mainly produced, eugenists developed their own form of negative eugenics for the regulation of female biotypes. Gender was in fact a critical variable, because it was through the socialisation of maternity towards eugenic goals that women’s proper role in the modem state was thought to be defined. The Argentine eugenists much admired Mussolini’s state rhetoric and programme of ‘family protection’, a programme whose pro-natalist, anti-abortion, and anti-feminist ideology was highly congruent with their own.


https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/019165999290087S/pdf?md5=78514568b005a672d10a46a947985b60&pid=1-s2.0-019165999290087S-main.pdf

3:25 Marx didn't want to get rid of people of Jewish background, perhaps ethnic distinctiveness, but he did attack the Jewish confession.

Some would count that as Antisemitism ....

3:34 Tell me again, when exactly were Italian small farmers forcefully collectivised in Italy?

You know, what Lenin did once, and Stalin did again to them.

Under Tito, small farmers weren't, large landowners were, even that didn't happen in Italy, unless you can give me news of it.

Under Franco, small farmers were fiscally disadvantaged and encouraged to sell to bigger farmers, to an extent that Carlism wouldn't have done, but Franco was not as bad as de Gaulle (let alone Mitterand) and the French weren't as bas as Swedes, and we in our turn weren't as bad as actual Commie régimes.

4:50 If you want to research Fascism, what were you doing in Berlin?

Hitler was in a Commie régime in 1919.

Mussolini, Franco, Salazar, Dollfuss and Schuschnigg never were that, nor was Perón.

(To be continued? I halt here, directly after a very obvious blunder!)