co-authors are other participants quoted. I haven't changed content of thr replies, but quoted it part by part in my replies, interspersing each reply after relevant part. Sometimes I have also changed the order of replies with my retorts, so as to prioritate logical/topical over temporal/chronological connexions. That has also involved conflating more than one message. I have also left out mere insults.
Pages
- Home
- Other blogs, same writer
- A thread from Catholic.com (more may be added)
- Answering Steve Rudd
- Have these dialogues taken place? Yes.
- Copyright issues on blogposts with shared copyright
- I think I wrote a mistaken word somewhere on youtube - or perhaps not
- What is Expertise? Some Things It is Not.
- It Seems Apocalypse is Explained in a Very Relevant Part
- Dialoguing Mainly with Adversaries
- Why do my Posts Right Here Not Answer YOUR Questio...
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
I Have Never Tried to Justify Sodomy or Gay Marriage
FACT CHECK: "Jesus Never Said Anything About Homosexuality."
David Cipriano | 7 March 2024
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O6MmrDESjfY
I actually thought that in not directly naming sodomy, Our Lord was following a mitzvah of the old covenant.
THEN I find:
But fornication, and all uncleanness, or covetousness, let it not so much as be named among you, as becometh saints:
[Ephesians 5:3]
Oops, NT, but Jesus set the example. It's sufficiently clear from other things that sodomy is a mortal sin, and from Mt 5 that even the voluntary desire of it is a mortal sin.
Other thing. Not everything that the man who coined the word "homosexual" considered as a paraphilia is ipso facto a sin.
Krafft-Ebing was just thinking of whether it could in certain cases land you in prison.
In Austria, for instance, a 14 year old girl could marry with permission of the parents, but had to wait to 21 without it. If you seduced someone's daughter and they didn't want her to marry you, you were in trouble, hence the term hebephilia was coined, to described a propensity which wouldn't automatically land anyone in either Hell or (his pov) prison, but which could in many cases, given the laws, land someone in prison.
Never ever is the Bible condemning simply an age difference, see for instance Ruth.
But neither is the Bible condoning what [Krafft-Ebing] meant by pedophilia, since that's how Jews twisted the story of Rebecca by very wild exegesis.
3:13 That we don't have a record of in the written NT canon.
3:24 It's also very possible given things that are getting more fashionable in the end times, that He actually did mention this in connection with the Days of Noah.
Eating and drinking, marrying and being given in marriage.
This could be code for cannibalism, vampyrism, same sex marriage from the male and from the female perspective.
Simply because eating, drinking, marrying and being given in marriage in the normal way would not in themselves indicate gross wickedness. God didn't simply send the Flood for worldliness and forgetfulness of Himself, and no more, Genesis 6 says everyone was thinking of evil, whether it means everyone wanted to do evil, or it means very many who didn't particularly were nevertheless forced to think of the evil that was being done to them, either way, we see lots of evil taking away freedoms and decencies. Hence the grosser interpretation of the four verbs.
4:32 Technically, you cannot justify or accuse homosexuality.
It's per se not an act. Sodomy may be the act of a homosexual, of a bisexual or even of a heterosexual who is ... trying to humilitate someone, is being humiliated, does it for money (and if he's still heterosexual, it means he hasn't done it very often).
The one thing you can definitely say is, Jesus no more condemns people for being homosexuals than for being cleptomaniacs. He does however condemn unrepented sodomy or mortally sinful thefth. (Unlike sodomy, not all thefth is mortally sinful).
You could be a very honest man while living out cleptomania, like if you were pickpocketting people who paid for courses on how to defend themselves against pickpockets and then gave back the wallets. I have more than once said, being homosexual doesn't mean you have no right to marriage. NOT being opposite sex of someone is why you don't have the right to marry that someone. James VI and I was married to Anne of Denmark, and that was not sinful, even if some things he did with men pretty obviously was. And as obviously, he could never have been married to those men. Josh Weed was one better, for long, I think four daughters were born before he cracked and took a lover, and even then it might be because he was a shrink (marriage councellor), which could imply idolatry (Romans 1).
4:49 Being gay is often enough used to mean active attempts to live out homosexuality in sinful ways, so, yes, being gay would be sinful.
In some cases (like Josh Weed or a celibate artist I know), "being gay" meant / means being homosexual, without trying to live it out. And with a combat against such desires. That on the other hand would not be sinful.
Monday, March 10, 2025
How Many Jews Will Tovia Singer Convert to Christianity?
How Many Jews Will Tovia Singer Convert to Christianity? · Tovia Singer Judges Monotheletism ...
Did Jacob Predict the Coming of Jesus When He Blessed Judah? - Rabbi Tovia Singer
Tovia Singer | 9 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QP6Ijeoq3cg
3:39 I think you are actually wrong.
The staff of kingship means sovereignty.
While you may not count Daniel 13 as Scripture, you would count it as history. Susanna was going to be stoned, except that Daniel proved her innocense. And, here is the kicker, no one from the Babylonian side was interfering. When Stephen was stoned, Paul had to keep the cloaks as well as keeping a lookout for Romans, or the Romans would have interrupted that. But in Babylon, it was not like that.
So, from King David on, Judah always enjoyed sovereignty. Up to Herod the Great and Archelaos. THEN the Romans took that away.
So, the Messiah already came, more precisely under Herod the Great's autonomy, he was not completely sovereign, but he could send soldiers to some villages. Herod Antipas couldn't.
He had the capacity to put John the Baptist into prison, but not to make a public execution, this prophet was murdered in prison.
And he sent, and beheaded John in the prison
[Matthew 14:10]
Pilate therefore said to them: Take him you, and judge him according to your law. The Jews therefore said to him: It is not lawful for us to put any man to death
[John 18:31]
They didn't mean according to the Torah, they meant according to the Romans. BY THEN the Messiah had already come.
4:14 I obviously disagree about the Maccabeans.
While they were not of the line of Judah, but of Levi, they were doing rule of a sovereign kind in Judah, and therefore they guaranteed the non-interruption of sovereignty or near-sovereignty from King David to ... 6 AD. Before which, Jesus had come.
- David Katz
- @davidkatz341
- It doesn't matter whether you agree or disagree. That is not with the versus mean. Maccabees were initially a great family of kohannim. But they did which was forget and claimed the kingship. The verse doesn't mean that there will be a king always on the throne because clearly they were huge gaps when there wasn't a game. What it means is the kingship is the line of Judah.
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @hglundahl
- @davidkatz341 You forget that sovereignty is a kind of kingship of the community.
As I have mentioned in another comment.
Judah was always able to punish its criminals, even during the Babylonian captivity, but this was taken away in 6 AD ... when the Messias was already born.
@ Wait, are the Maccabees you say were wrong after the ones described in 1 and 2 Maccabees?
Because, while I have a duty to honour the men described with approval there, it seems John Hyrcanus was the first king of the Hasmonaean dynasty and does not fall in that category ...
My bad, if so.
- David Katz
- @hglundahl The Book of Maccabees is not in the Jewish canon it's in the Christian canon. They were great leaders during the rebellion that We remember during Hanukkah. But as kohanim their members of the tribe of Levi and are forbidden to take the kingship.
@hglundahl I don't understand your point. Judah could punish criminals? You could have a governor. We had judges. But the kingship is of Judah. And by the way, I don't understand how Christians get by 2nd Kings. To be king and to be the final Messiah you have to be of Judah. Jesus is not of Judah. That's the end of the issue if Christians want to insist Jesus was miraculously born of a virgin. I mean the whole Matthew 1:23 misappropriation of Isaiah 7:14 is beyond absurd. However if we're going on the Christian claim then Jesus cannot be the Messiah because he had no earthly father. Christians make stuff up to fix this like they try to say Jesus is of Judah through Mary. Nice try but there's no documentation on that and why does the Christian Bible go out of its way to print two separate genealogies of Joseph? By the way genealogies that do not agree.
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @ First, I am glad you honour the men who are mentioned in the book of Maccabees, even if you don't count them as canon.
Second, the interpretation of Tovia Singer and yourself of the verse is faulty because the verse actually doesn't mention king as such. Two words are mentioned:
šê·ḇeṭ - translated sceptre or tribe in various contexts
chaqaq - translated staff or commanders
So, the idea of sovereignty stands.
"Jesus is not of Judah."
Check Matthew 1.
Not having a physical earthly father doesn't mean He had no foster father, which legally counts.
"Jesus is of Judah through Mary. Nice try but there's no documentation on that"
Yes, there is.
Luke 3 gives a genealogy where someone is foster father on Joseph's side and real father on Mary's.
I think that answers your last point too.
@davidkatz341 Relation of Isaiah 7 and Matthew:
How Jews Changed the Scripture to Erase Jesus as the Messiah
Christian Chronicles | 16 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTaeeOSOZRY
- David Katz
- @hglundahl I'm aware of the apologetics that Christians come up with. But tribal affiliation is patrilineal. You know you're talking about the Jewish people. We know our scripture better than anyone. There is no such thing as tribal affiliation through adoption. And when there is no Jewish father the child has no travel affiliation. It's as simple as that. Now you mention Luke gives a genealogy where someone is a foster father. Can you point to the verse that says that?
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @davidkatz341 "There is no such thing as tribal affiliation through adoption."
So, what about levirate?
"Can you point to the verse that says that?"
No, but to a tradition. Here is a quote from the Haydock comment to Luke 3:
Remarks on the two Genealogies of Jesus Christ.
To make some attempt at an elucidation of the present very difficult subject of inquiry, we must carry in our minds, 1. That in the Scripture language the word begat, applies to the remote, as well as the immediate, descendant of the ancestor; so that if Marcus were the son, Titus the grandson, and Caius the great-grandson of Sempronius, it might, in the language of Scripture, be said, that Sempronius begat Caius. This accounts for the omission of several descents in St. Matthew. 2. The word begat, applies not only to the natural offspring, but to the offspring assigned to the ancestor by law. 3. If a man married the daughter and only child of another, he became in the view of the Hebrew law the son of that person, and thus was a son assigned to him by law. The two last positions shew in what sense Zorobabel was the son both of Neri and Salathiel, and Joseph the son both of Jacob and of Heli, or Joachim. --- "St. Matthew, in descending from Abraham to Joseph, the spouse of the blessed Virgin, speaks of a son properly so called, and by way of generation, Abraham begot Isaac, &c. But St. Luke in ascending from Jesus to God himself, speaks of a son properly or improperly so called. On this account he make use of an indeterminate expression, in saying, the son of Joseph, who was of Heli. That St. Luke does not always speak of a son properly called, and by way of generation, appears from the first and last he names; for Jesus was only the putative son of Joseph, because Joseph was the spouse of Mary, the mother of Christ; and Adam was only the son of God by creation. This being observed, we must acknowledge in the genealogy in St. Luke, two sons improperly so called, that is, two sons-in-law, instead of sons. As among the Hebrews, the women entered not into the genealogy, when a house finished by a daughter, instead of naming the daughter in the genealogy, they named the son-in-law, who had for father-in-law the father of his wife. The two sons-in-law mentioned in St. Luke are Joseph, the son-in-law of Heli, and Salathiel, the son-in-law of Neri. This remarks clears up the difficulty. Joseph, the son of Jacob, in St. Matthew, was the son-in-law of Heli, in St. Luke; and Salathiel, the son of Jechonias, in St. Matthew, was the son-in-law of Neri, in St. Luke. Mary was the daughter of Heli, Eliacim, or Joacim, or Joachim. Joseph, the son of Jacob, and Mary, the daughter of Heli, had a common origin; both descending from Zorobabel, Joseph by Abiud the eldest, and Mary by Resa, the younger brother. Joseph descended from the royal branch of David, of which Solomon was the chief; and Mary from the other branch, of which Nathan was the chief. by Salathiel, the father of Zorobabel, and son of Jechonias, Joseph and Mary descended from Solomon, the son and heir of David. And by the wife of Salathiel, the mother of Zorobabel, and daughter of Neri, of which Neri Salathiel was the son-in-law, Joseph and Mary descended from Nathan, the other son of David, so that Joseph and Mary re-united in themselves all the blood of David. St. Matthew carries up the genealogy of Jesus to Abraham; this was the promise of the Messias, made to the Jews; St. Luke carries it up to Adam, the promise of the Messias, made to all men."
Whatever the difficulties attending the genealogies may be, it is evident that they arise from our imperfect knowledge of the laws, usages, and idiom of the Jews, from our ignorance of the true method of reconciling the seeming inconsistencies, or from some corruptions that in process of time may possibly have crept into the text. The silence of the enemies of the gospel, both heathen and Jewish, during even the first century, is itself a sufficient proof, that neither inconsistency nor corruption could be then alleged against this part of the evangelical history. If the lineal descent of Jesus from David were not indisputable, he could not possess the character essential to the Messias, nor any right to the Jewish throne. We may confidently then assert, that his regular lineal descent from David could not be disproved, since it was not even disputed at a time when alone it could have been done so successfully; and by those persons who were so deeply interested in falsifying the first Christian authorities.
4:47 We admit there was for certain periods no Davidic King, but we do not admit there was no sovereignty.
Royal staffs in the hands of actual kings or "royal staffs held in keeping" by judges or priests or other people who could exercise an authority of sovereignty or near-sovereignty.
Like the Maccabees against Antiochus, like Daniel under Nebuchadnezzar. Unless you will say Daniel 13 is a complete fabrication, on top of excluding it from Scripture. I somehow don't think you will.
5:11 "if you have a king, it will have to be a Davidic king"
This is not grammatically possible.
The blessing said Judah was not going to lack kingship, i e for instance the right to execute criminals (publically, not by lynching or murdering someone in prison who wasn't even technically accused of a crime).
5:59 I did look it up. The next verse says:
And after this the children of Israel shall return, and shall seek the Lord their God, and David their king: and they shall fear the Lord, and his goodness in the last days
[Osee (Hosea) 3:5]
So, this doesn't mean the Messiah hasn't come yet, it means the Jews had not converted yet during the "many days" ...
Osee 3:5 ... parallels the prophecy in Apocalypse 7. In the end times, Jews will convert.
"shall return, and shall seek the Lord their God" obviously means a conversion, not just coming back physically to the Holy Land.
6:52 Osee only said so of the children of Israel.
For the children of Israel shall sit many days without king, and without prince, and without sacrifice, and without altar, and without ephod, and without theraphim
[Osee (Hosea) 3:4]
But by then the Messiah already has, for long time, had the Gentiles:
The sceptre shall not be taken away from Juda, nor a ruler from his thigh, till he come that is to be sent, and he shall be the expectation of nations
[Genesis 49:10]
So, Osee and Genesis 49 together make perfect sense if the Messiah is a Davidic King, but one who "for many days" is ruling over Gentiles rather than over children of Israel. Which is precisely what the Catholic Church claims has happened. And, by the way, I do not condone Antipope Ratzinger and his taking a distance from "replacement theology" ....
7:05 Sacrifice ... it's again only the children of Israel who are without a sacrifice.
For from the rising of the sun even to the going down, my name is great among the Gentiles, and in every place there is sacrifice, and there is offered to my name a clean oblation: for my name is great among the Gentiles, saith the Lord of hosts
[Malachias (Malachi) 1:11]
We have an altar, whereof they have no power to eat who serve the tabernacle
[Hebrews 13:10]
So, Jews lost the right to public sacrifice a bit later than the one to sovereignty. By then a sacrifice that was ongoing among the Gentiles for the last 2000 years and still is, was already in place.
No, Genesis 49:10 is very far from a nightmare for the Catholic Church.
Labels:
Christian Chronicles,
David Katz,
Tovia Singer
Narnia Channel Censored
Narnia Channel Censored · Update on Narnia Channel — It's Back!
I commented under more than one, and one of them found the way to this blog.
The Hidden Meaning of Names in Narnia Explained | Narnian Lore | Into the Wardrobe
Into the Wardrobe, 11 Sept. 2023
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FngFX5qNcgY
Well, now ...
Sunday, March 9, 2025
Marketing Questions
How to Create DEMAND Around What You Do (From a Marketing Perspective)
Lauren Erickson | 9 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3tuUCSw5ktQ
- Comment II
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @hglundahl
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- What do I do if my competitors are interested in keeping me small?
- Lauren Erickson
- @laurenericks0n
- Identify their weaknesses and position yourself in those gaps. I'd also think about who you know how complements what you're doing or would be good to collab with. Fastest way to grow is through cross-promotion!
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @ Did exactly that, see other answer.
Cross-promotion is right now a one way affair, I promote them, they bless me or feel amused, but do not reciprocate.
- Comment I
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- What do I do if the readers I'm actually getting are actively putting wedges between me and my goal demographic?
- Lauren Erickson
- Who's doing similar work as you but better? I'd consider some of the biggest differences between you and them to help you attract your target audience. Might be language, positioning, presentation, delivery style, etc.
- Hans-Georg Lundahl
- @laurenericks0n Where did my comment go?
I answered, on Young Earth Creationism, obviously CMI and AiG are doing similar work, but they are not providing for instance a bidecadal calibration for carbon dates in Biblical chronology, and they are not providing an archaeological identity for Babel (I do, Göbekli Tepe, which gives me the carbon dates for beginning and end of the Babel event, between Noah's death and Peleg's birth).
On Geocentrism, Robert Sungenis is doing similar work.
He is however not doing angelic movers, and as a consequence posits a purely mechanistic reason for parallax, stars being tied to the Sun. Neo-Tychonian. As I posit angelic movers, I can also see the "parallax" as performed by these, and not parallactic, no clue as to trig (one angle and zero distance = no clue), and this gives me the possibility to posit the shell of fix stars one light day up, doing away with the Distant Starlight problem for a recent cosmos, and also allowing Heaven where we hope to go, where Jesus is reigning, to be coordinates of Jerusalem one light day up.
I am dealing massively with readers who refuse to hand me on to people who might really be interested, at least it has been the case for very long.
Illustration of my actual readers cutting me off from those who would be interested:
Saturday, March 8, 2025
Friday, March 7, 2025
Papal Prophecy from Armagh or Clairvaux? Sure.
Anyway, a brief pretended "debunk" by Dan McClellan is not cutting it the other way:
On the “Prophecy of the Popes”
Dan McClellan | 6 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BXf7kUXJGWY
2:32 Aquila rapax? I think that was Pius VI or VII, either of whom was in some way agressed by Napoleon, an Emperor (aquila) who was at least in Italian eyes, as well as English ones rapacious.
Crux a cruce? Pius IX, who was attacked by Savoy, a previous principality, duchy, which had a cross in the coat of arms and gave that Pope a cross to bear.
You mentioned* Orvieto:
Milan is an old city having been founded in 400 B.C.
[About the Popes from the Twelfth Century to the End of Time
https://www.catholictradition.org/Papacy/prophecies.htm]
Lilium et rosa
[The lily and the rose]
MATEO BARBERINI = Urban VIII (1623-1644)
He was born in 1568 and educated under the Jesuits. In 1601 he was appointed Papal Legate to France and in 1604 Archbishop of Nazareth. Later he was sent as Nuncio to Paris and in 1606 he was made a Cardinal by Paul V. He was elected Pope in 1623 and throughout his reign he concerned himself with the affairs of France and England. He died in 1644.
There is no doubt that his particular interest in the affairs of France (fleur de lis) and England (the rose) seems the most obvious explanation.
Quick google confirms he was:
a) involved in the rivalry between France and "Austria" (HRE + Spain)
b) involved in civil rights for Catholics under English rule
c) involved in abolition of slavery, wait, less concerned with England and France, since he was** on the lines of Bartolomé de la Casas:
In a Bull, dated 22 April, 1639, he strictly prohibited slavery of any kind among the Indians of Paraguay, Brazil, and the entire West Indies.
But a and b, he actually did meddle in the French lily and the English rose, which could obviously be a response to his knowing the prophecy.
However, Aquila Rapax and Crux de Cruce were not similarily able to get produced by target chosing to fulfil it. Like the rule about the Paschal lamb couldn't be fulfilled by Jesus' purely human choice on Calvary.
Lumen in caelo
[A light in the sky]
GIOACHINO PECCI = Leo XIII (1878-1903)
This is the first of Malachy's prophecies for the years after 1590 which appears to be a straightfoward allusion to the Pope's amorial bearings which show a blasing star in the coat of arms. His great encylicals could also be called "a light in the sky"
There was both a comet and a meteor shower in 1878.***
4:51 I would agree that Peter the Roman isn't Antipope Bergoglio.
If Pius XII wasn't Pope, one could link Pastor Angelicus to Michael I, as being devout to the Archangel Michael, and Pastor et Nauta to Michael II, who has arguably cruised between the Philippines and some other places.
Notes:
* An expected Pope not coming from Orvieto.
De antiquitate Urbis = Gregory XIV (1590-1591)
** Pope Urban VIII / Catholic Encyclopedia
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15218b.htm
*** I checked from a vague memory of a more detailed comment on the prophecy.
https://www.sciencephoto.com/media/895754/view/meteor-shower-1878
Thursday, March 6, 2025
Yes, He Was that Smart. Not even Technically a Miracle
Was Boy Jesus Really That Smart?
The Rabyd Atheist | 5 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7g3lPQOq5CU
0:37 For St. Luke's Gospel, the witness on some things is the Blessed Virgin Mary.
I'd say that's as credible as you get.
On the same occasion, St. Luke made an icon of the Blessed Virgin. A copy of a copy of it is called, variously, Our Lady of Perpetual Help or, by the Greeks, Hodegetria. As he was Greek, he did not relate to the ban on images, and Our Lady knew Our Lord had miraculously put images on cloth, so She was OK with it too.
Given St. Joseph was also present at the occasion, his children from a previous marriage could also witness to St. Luke. Like St. James, Brother-of-God, the first single monarchic bishop of Jerusalem.
2:07 Two witnesses is a criterium for judges.
St. Luke wasn't a witness, he was judging witness accounts.
2:32 "the author of Luke is anonymous"
That's not modern scholarship. That's modernist scholarship, i e part of what Pope St. Pius X called a synthesis of all heresies.
It began with Markan priority, the traditional account of the Gospels (both Augustine and Clement of Alexandria, though differring on the relation between Mark and Luke) places Matthew as first Gospeller. In Bismarck's Germany, among Liberal Protestants, Markan priority was convenient, because it allowed Liberals to stamp Matthean prooftexts for the papacy as "later accretions" ...
The theory pre-existed the Kulturkampf, but gained vastly in traction by the Kulturkampf.
The criteria that modernist Bible scholars use to determine or dis-determine authorships are such that, if consistently applied in other fields of Ancient scholarship, for instance Latin or Greek literature, would cripple knowledge. They are for instance such that on their criterium, you couldn't know that Caesar (the one who was killed on the Ides of March) wrote Bellum Gallicum. I've been confronted by those types of criteria, and I've taken a look at what they would mean for Bellum Gallicum. And mind you, all scholars accept Bellum Gallicum and Bellum Civile as authored by Caesar, except BG book VIII which specifically tells us that Caesar confided authorship to someone else for that. The idea "if Moses wrote the Exodus, why no first person" would also doom Bellum Gallicum, if accepted as a good argument against a witness.
2:51 No, it is not "conjecture and speculation" it is straight off the tradition of the Church.
2:53 "No historical attestation elsewhere."
You are here applying the criterium of the so called Weibull school about historic research and presentation.
It works fine for early modern times to the present, because we have so much printed documentation. We have records of debates, and so, that Laurentius Magni was named archbishop of Uppsala in 1527, when it was too late, when Gustav Wasa had given up on being in temporary schism, hoping the Pope would change his mind, and got fullblown Lutheran, this is a fact that can be verified from:
- Laurentius Magni or his brother Olaus Magni
- Vatican archives
- Gustav Wasa's men, probably Laurentius Petri (the Nerician), a disciple of Luther himself, or his brother Olaus Petri.
So, you probably can get at least 3 independent sources for the fact.
We are close to 500 years after the fact. However, multiply that by 4. 2000 years ago is a very different story. As well as anything further back. We have one source for the Finding in the Temple, unless it's also mentioned in Proto-Gospel of St. James, in that case 2. We also have exactly one ancient source for Caesar building a bridge over Lake Geneva. Caesar in Bellum Gallicum (it's the campaign against Orgetorix or its aftermath, I forget which). Go far enough back, probably to before the 11th C. revolution in reading and writing, perhaps earlier than that in Byzantium, and the criterium completely breaks down.
2:59 "to tell what characters are feeling"
I don't think St. Luke or anyone else is indulging in many speculations about someone's inner feelings. Those of Mary, he had Her as the source. As to the teachers in the Temple, well, "they were astonished" must be read as "they expressed astonishment" ... a modern novelist might have allowed them to make up to 5 utterances, in order that each could be shown in some shade of astonishment, but papyrus was not as cheap, and scrolls tended to be short even for reasons of maintaining the scroll.
I think you haven't mastered the 1st C. context of the culture of writing in general, back then.
3:30 Before a judge, hearsay is inacceptable.
In history, authors are to be presumed as being judges. I e, Luke is to be presumed to have better sources than just hearsay, unless you can show he usually bungles things, which you can't, and Luke himself is not hearsay, but a judge about the evidence available to him.
4:20 "anyone could write anything about Jesus' boyhood, and believers were going to believe it"
That's a pretty wild reconstruction.
First, I'm not sure the account of Infancy Gospel of St. Thomas are false. But second, that text gained only local traction and was never accepted as a canonical Gospel. Perhaps "partial" is better than "local" but anyway. If there had been no scepticism from believers about it, it would have made it into the canon. It's not just absent from the canon decided in 380's and 90's, but the Muratorian fragment doesn't seem to have it, and it was generous enough to include Apocalypse of St. Peter. As far as I could make out in wikipedia (which could be vandalised), but also a google search, Melito of Sardis is only giving an OT canon.
Third. You are not just ignoring Church Tradition, you are presuming the contrary is true about the Church's back then due diligence about the Gospels.
5:10 No, the Bible actually doesn't indicate that Mary had more children.
St. Joseph had children from a wife who had died before the Gospel account starts.
6:04 The closest we get to such a testimony from rabbis is:
- Gamaliel
- Joseph of Arimathaea
- Nicodemus
all converted to Christianity, sooner with the latter two, later with the former (arguably after both his disciples Paul and Barnabas were already doing ministry).
As to getting such a testimony from Rabbinic Judaism, the expectation would be very naive. All over the four Gospels, we see a later generation of Pharisees trying to test Jesus. One motive would be, He gathered disciples. But given the acrimony of the over the top testing, asking for a miracle just after He had performed one, a probably motive would be sons feeling slighted that their dads had admired Jesus more than them. The Mishna was assembled by committees of a fairly anti-Christian bias. Any testimony of the kind you say would be welcome would have been weeded out well before the Mishna was finally assembled.
6:19 Do we even know there was any Rabbinic teaching in Nazareth at this point?
Because, I haven't even seen evidence Nazareth at this point has a Beth Sepher.
By the way, I don't see any early Church Father making the boy's wisdom a direct argument for divinity.
Bede does, but his view on the passage is too late to be a motive for it. In Catena Aurea*, I'll cite Bede and a Greek expositor:
Origen makes it a consequence of his divinity. I'll cite him too:
ORIGEN. Because moreover He was the Son of God, He is found in the midst of the doctors, enlightening and instructing them. But because He was a little child, He is found among them not teaching but asking questions, as it is said, Sitting in the midst of the doctors, hearing them, and asking them questions. And this He did as a duty of reverence, that He might set us an example of the proper behaviour of children, though they be wise and learned, rather to hear their masters than teach them, and not to vaunt themselves with empty boasting. But He asked not that He might learn, but that asking He might instruct. For from the same source of learning is derived both the power of asking and answering wisely, as it follows, All who heard him were astonished at his wisdom.
BEDE. To shew that He was a man, He humbly listened to the masters; but to prove that He was God, He divinely answered those who spake.
GREEK EXPOSITOR. (Metaphrastes vel Geometer.) He asks questions with reason, He listens with wisdom, and answers with more wisdom, so as to cause astonishment. As it follows, And they who saw it were astonished.
If you'd say "there was a Beth Sepher everywhere" ... no, attendance at such only became mandatory with the High Priest Joshua ben Gamla, who died early in the Jewish war.
7:40 "Matthew seems to indicate that the family was always residents in Bethlehem"
But he actually doesn't.
8:03 Romans were pretty fond of tax collecting from provincials.
I think you presume from the fact that a tax in Judaea after Archelaos was removed was the first and sparked a revolt.
This doesn't mean there was no much more humdrum taxing in Galilee, and St. Joseph would have stated the intention of going to Bethlehem in order to avoid those tax collectors, and either he was pleasantly astonished to find no census official in Bethlehem "what? the Centurion said all the world is being taxed!" ... or his intention to get taxed was straight face, and he enrolled to pay tax to the Temple instead.
He probably changed his mind about Roman tax collectors when hearing about the child killing in Bethlehem.
8:13 "once the tax is over"
There is no explicit mention that St. Joseph actually did enroll.
"there is no flight to Egypt in Luke"
Could Our Lady have found that memory a bit traumatising? Even if Jesus was saved, She would have known that lots of the children killed were children She had seen or that St. Joseph knew (not sure if the account is compatible with his having property there, but one could imagine he had leased out his house and had to seek accomodation elsewhere for that reason, or he could have visited Bethlehem with relatives there).
8:53 "running from the law"
More like, from a crime by the state. Note, by the vassal Kingdom of Judaea, at this point still semi-independent.
9:08 St. Matthew certainly didn't use Mark. Neither did St. Luke.
The most credible option for the Synoptic problem as to often identical wordings is that given by St. Clement of Alexandria. When St. Luke came to the first Pope, Peter, to get a stamp of approval, this Chief Apostle was enthusiastic, read alternatingly from Matthew and Luke, adding own comments, and St. Mark (at least at the beginning of the process, one may imagine) sthenographed the Gospel that St. Peter was finally dictating, but as this wasn't the intention, just a verification, the human initiative to the second Gospel comes down to St. Mark.
As he himself founded the Church of Alexandria, I think St. Clement was in a very good position to know.
9:33 St. Matthew couldn't know about St. Luke, since he was first.
St. Luke didn't learn about St. Matthew's Gospel until he came to see St. Peter.
Probably, if Theophilus is Theophilus Ben Hanan, the people he interviewed in Jerusalem deliberately hid the Gospel of Matthew from him. But their wording as oral witnesses to St. Luke may have been influenced by it.
9:48 St. Matthew, as one of the twelve, didn't have to depend on oral tradition, except from the Holy Family (probably St. James Brother-of-God) for the childhood narrative.
St. Luke explicitly does receive a tradition, but is careful to receive it first hand.
Event > X > Luke = yes.
Event > X > Y > Luke = no.
10:37 Not sure how much information Jesus showed above the expected (except it wouldn't have been expected from a home-schooler), more like He received the fullness of judgement about the information He had.
While Jesus was arguably a home-schooler, His Mother had been raised in the Temple. That's why She knew exactly She was being compared to Jael and Judith, wondered why, and when St. Elisabeth adds a bit, recognises Genesis 3:15. Which, given Satan's victory is sin, must have meant She was sinless.
So, right before the Magnificat, She got confirmed She was Mother of God, which She already knew, but explained (in terms She, as raised in the Temple, would immediately understand, quicker than Robert Langdon, comparing only qualifications in "symbolology") She was sinless. And She was as happy as a bright midsummer's day.
This background was not common knowledge to the simple teachers of the law in the Temple, only the priests knew it. And this mind raised Jesus, who had come from Her flesh. The mind that was happier to obey God than to be His close and privileged relative. Just as Jesus forwarded to someone in the sense of "give my ma the compliment she likes best, she deserves that too" (Luke 11).
Is there never anyone who ever struck you as admirable because of surprising takes in his or her judgement?
11:40 Look. In the early Mishnaic period, which begins before the NT, there were these two very well known rabbis, Hillel I and Shammai.**
Since then, there is some kind of understanding among Jews, you must either be "house of Hillel" or "house of Shammai" ... my likeliest candidate for what astonished the teachers is, He showed them how to be both.
As He was homeschooled, He didn't start out in one of the schools. As He was devout, to a Torah which He shared with both, it's probable He was giving a third angle. And as the two angles were right then a problem (which humanly He might not have known, and actually didn't show Himself as knowing, providing only the solutions), this astonished. You may know the clip from Young Messiah, where, a few years earlier, in Alexandria, Our Lord is asked "when was God ever a Carpenter?" and is met with answers from what was common knowledge and would have been like First Grade Sunday School knowledge, or comparable, since back then it was obviously not "Sunday" school, but with a judgement the man hadn't expected. (I'm less fond of the answer about earthly paradise).
11:49 Yes, the Samaritan woman was certainly divine prophecy.
But back to Luke 2, St. John Chrysostom comments:
CHRYSOSTOM. (sup. Joh. Hom. 20.) The Lord truly did no miracle in His childhood, yet this one fact St. Luke mentions, which made men look with wonder upon Him.
In other words, what astonished the teachers was not miraculous knowledge, just maturity not expected in those years. The reaction would have been similar to how the Yanuka is seen these days.
12:27 Given Our Lady was raised in the Temple and first cousin to Elisabeth Cohen, given St. Joseph was of the house of David, it's impossible that they would not have possessed the Torah.
On a very, very, very mush lesser note, I was once teased for being the smartass of the class, and in 6th grade someone gave me an equation for 7th grade maths, and I did it. That day, I was not teased any more.
But obviously, my mum was an ace in mathematics, had "capital A" up to an ablation of the appendix, and from then on "lower case a" in the Swedish grading system. (Yes, she made a point of this). Mathematics were part of her and my own hobbies, and I'm basically ashamed of now forgetting how to do magic squares of six sides or more. Back then I knew. Solving a first degree equation was not super hard. Even if it was my first time around doing it on my own, I think I had seen one done in one of the math books I loved.
Mozart was more precocious about music. Neither of these examples and probably not the teaching of the teachers either, was strictly speaking miraculous.
12:47 If He was both, we would expect different contexts to provide different occasions for either.
Catholic theology doesn't by that Jesus, even as man, didn't have prophetic knowledge of the day and hour, some explain it "doesn't know" = "doesn't make known" ("I don't know" = "I won't tell you" ... in Catholic moral theology this doesn't count as a lie). Some say His physical body, His own person, knew, but His mystical body, the Church, doesn't.
* Catena Aurea by St. Thomas Aquinas, Luke, Chapter 2
https://www.ecatholic2000.com/catena/untitled-63.shtml
** One can consider the contributions of Hillel I and Shammai as being in legalities of the Old Law the equivalent of my doing the upper and lower boundaries for the sum sqrt(5) + ... + sqrt(13) as it has to be lower than 27 but bigger than 23. I got bigger than 23 from sqrt(5) to sqrt(8) being four sqrts bigger than 2, and the remaining sqrts being five sqrts, equal to or bigger than 3. 4*2 + 5*3 = 8 + 15 = 23. Then I get back to the video, where Prime Newtons explains how the lower limit must be 26:
Romanian Mathematics Olympiad
Prime Newtons | 1 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cqlpr0W0-34
Ah yes, each of the paired sqrts is bigger than 34, and each should contribute 23/4 if the lower limit is 26 and we leave out 3 as unpaired sqrt(9). Obvilously. Well, the teachers of the law must have felt something similar when hearing Jesus after knowing Hillel I and Shammai.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


