Saturday, March 15, 2025

Where I Have My Info About Gaza From


In response to Ali-Marie Ingram:


Stuff going on in the Gaza Strip…
Ali-Marie Ingram | 15 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f6iWEO5RHLI


33 AD to c. 325 AD. Christians in the Holy Land are mainly Hebrews. I know that because of Stephan Borgehammar's How the Holy Cross was Found, among other things, the Church of Jerusalem got to Pella (al Fahl, Jordan) in AD 70 and then went back (some of them, some remaining in Pella), so, there is a continuity of population in the Holy Land from Acts two and eight to Constantine and his mother. The book is mainly about how this influences her chances of finding the cross and then different accounts of what happened and how these seem to indicate the accounts go back to the actual event. The info about Christians in the Holy Land is however part of a chapter I or chapter Intro or sth.

325 AD to 637 (or so) AD. Christians in the Holy Land are mainly Hebrews, and lots more of the Hebrews are Christians after Constantine. EXCEPT, during the invasion of Chosroës II, they often apostasise and start persecuting Christians, and when Heraclius returns (connected to Elevation of the Holy Cross), they either remain Jewish and go to Persia, or they remain in the Holy Land and change religion once again and become Christians again. I know they are ethnically Hebrews, because Derwas Chitty's The Desert a City says that "they returned to the Judaism of their ancestors" rather than call it "apostasy" ... so, the Christians in the Holy Land as to ancestry were apparently something like Halakhic Jews, they could be accepted as Jews if they changed religion. The book by Derwas Chitty is mainly concerned with Egyptians founding monasticism. However when monks get to the Holy Land, they find monks already exist there, and the final chapter tells their story.

C. 637 AD. Christians in the Holy Land are under pressure to become Muslims and some actually do that. The final chapter of Derwas Chitty speaks of a Nomad tribe who used to be the "flock" of one monastery, and they get to the monastery and tell the monks "we are now Muslims, we are still your friends" ...

After c. 637 AD, the Christian population decreases and the Muslim increases, not mainly by immigration of those Soldiers, the ones who came with Omar, but by Christians apostatising to Islam. Same Christians as previously, so, mostly Hebrew.

And I have found no moment in history where this has ceased to be the case. Christian Hebrews and presumably (though this was not told by Derwas Chitty) Jewish Hebrews are the main origin of Muslims in the Holy Land (Beduins in Negev axcepted, arguably). This means, Palestinians today are Christian or Muslim Hebrews. THIS is more important than things that have happened lately, and obviously informs my stance on what has happened lately as well.

Yesterday I read in Le Monde Diplomatique (which is right now missing from the bags I took to the cyber, we'll see if I find it again when returning to my luggage) that in international law, one is supposed to determine in advance how many civilian casualties are acceptable for a given military target. US dismantling some Daesh stronghold was setting them at zero civilians for a common soldier, and five or ten or fifteen for a commander ("cadre"). Israel is in that article said to set the limits like ten civilians for a common soldier and one hundred for a commander. That would in any warfare be genocidal, but is especially distasteful when that war is in this case fratricidal.




How the Holy Cross Was Found: From Event to Mediaeval Legend
Relié – 1 mai 1991
Édition en Latin de Stephan Borgehammar (Auteur)
https://www.amazon.fr/How-Holy-Cross-Was-Found/dp/9122014322


[It's called Latin edition because a chunk features source texts in Latin]

Desert a City
Hardcover – Import, October 1, 1966
by Derwas J. Chitty (Author)
https://www.amazon.com/Desert-City-D-J-Chitty/dp/0631100202/


Le Monde diplomatique: Vider Gaza, ce vieux rêve israélien
par Alain Gresh | Mars 2025, en kiosques
https://www.monde-diplomatique.fr/2025/03/GRESH/68098

Troy Existed, the Trojan War Happened


If you check the details of the video, it may seem that the Trojan War as described by Homer telescopes several wars between Hittite (and post-Hittite?) Wilusans and the Ahhiyawa / Mycenaeans into one. For my part I would even have accepted the idea that details from the Hittite Egyptian conflict came into the Trojan War descriptions of Homer. But "includes details from elsewhere" while it means "didn't happen exactly as described" certainly doesn't mean "didn't happen at all" ....


Did Troy Actually Exist? Is The Iliad Real? Response To Leonidas Sparta
Metatron | 13 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qYHsMsP81tg


Is part two coming out?

The claim that cavalry only came with Neo-Assyrian Empire had come to my attention, and that would obviously challenge the Bible as King David lived before this time.

As a Biblical Inerrancy Apologist, I obviously look forward to part two!

8:44 Were they still vassals of the Hittites?

I thought Hattusha fell 1200 BC and Troy 1179 BC.

In other words, for twenty years, Trojans had no longer been vassals of the Hittites.

Part II, as I requested him to hurry with the promise:


Hittite Army Composition Full Historical Analysis
Metatron | 14 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E3BtfM8xsX8


10:09 From my memory, the final taking of Troy would have been 1179 BC?

Hattusha fell c. 1200 (or was abandoned).

But if I got the previous video correct, there were previous wars around Wilusa that also got reflected in Homer.

I would consider the inclusion of Egypt on the Greek side as a reflection of the Battle of Kadesh.

Paulogia's Scenario for Christianity with No Resurrection


NO RESURRECTION REQUIRED! How Christianity Probably Began.
Paulogia | 29 April 2024
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Isnl9A50ySY


Michael Lorton
@malvoliosf
Is Simon-Peter actually necessary? Wouldn’t a chance combination of rumors and forgery more than explain what happened?

Paulogia
@Paulogia
There is ample extra-Biblical evidence that someone named Peter was a leader of the early church, so your scenario doesn't quite fit in my opinion.

Michael Lorton
@Paulogia Are you thinking of 1 Clement? Almost everyone who knew Jesus would have been dead 96CE, so Clement was repeating something he was told. Maybe Saul made up the stories about Simon-Peter. In the balance, your theory I think has much to recommend it — all it requires is one distraught man making an honest mistake, and the rest is just the rumor-mill — but it’s not the only possibility.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@hglundahl
@malvoliosf Clement was consecreated bishop by St. Peter.

Note, episcopal consecration and accession to a specific see are two distinct things. Just after Peter consecrated him, he would have been more like Cardinal-Bishop than Pope.

But, supposing you pretend to put that down to "legend" (however that item is supposed to work) ... (yes, I know a thing or two about legends, that being a form of literature I enjoy and have studied on an amateur level, and with the Iliad at University) .... Clement succeeded Anacletus who succeeded Linus who directly succeeded Peter (and was elected by Peter on the deathbed).

You are kind of arguing as if James Madison could have been entirely wrong and a victim of Dweems in believing that the first president of the US was George Washington. Or Stephen of Bois could have been wrong in believing William the Conqueror was the first Norman King in England. Or as if Edwy could have been wrong in believing Athelstan was the first King of the English.

Michael Lorton
@ Tertullian claimed Clement was consecrated bishop by Peter. Everything we know about Clement, apart from an ambiguous fragment of a letter he might have authored, is rumor, hearsay, and guesswork.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@malvoliosf It's tradition of the Church.

You want to dispute Tertullian?

Dispute Dweems, not on the cherry tree, but on George Washington being the First President.

You are obviously all of this time as far as we can see dealing with a Church that has an organisation capable of good oral transmission of information.

Michael Lorton
@hglundahl Well, it’s also a tradition of the Church that Jesus was the Messiah. As I don’t believe that, obviously, I am willing to be somewhat skeptical of Church traditions.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@malvoliosf That's a traditional assessment ... not a direct claim of observed fact.

If you mean miracles, yes, those are observable facts, and if you don't believe traditions on these, it would be decent to explain how the error occurred.

Church traditions have a high degree of good transmission. They constantly make this claim, and they constantly back it up by agreeing, in the main, even when not being obviously able to check with each other from Jerusalem to Rome to Lyons on every item.

Michael Lorton
@hglundahl How did the error of reporting miracles occur? How does any error occur?

In this case, one person wanted something to be true — Jesus walked on water, Jesus rose from the dead, whatever — and he told another person it had really happened, and the other person believed it.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@malvoliosf "one person wanted something to be true"
"he told another person it had really happened, and the other person believed it."

Yes, but how?

If the early Church had been so disorganised as to allow free spreading or rumour, no problem. But this is not what we see in the sources.

@malvoliosf You may also adress how one man wanted Jesus walking on the water to be true, if there were no previous reports of it.

The originator of an error is not in the same position as a defender of an already established text.

Michael Lorton
@ There is no shortage of apocryphal, non-canonical, dubious, and outright fraudulent texts surviving from the early church, including far more apocryphal Gospels than canonical ones: the Gospel of Thomas, the Gospel of Basilides, the Gospel of Mary, even the Gospel of Judas, among others.

I don’t know if originality in a claim is an indicium of truth. Some of Jesus’s miracles were old standbys (like raising the dead and calming the waters) among miracle workers, but even if one were unique, that might be because it really happened, or it might be because the inventor was creative.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@malvoliosf You are equivocating.

Gospel of Thomas or of Judas are NOT from the Church. They are not just para-Gospels, they are from para-Churches.

As you know, there were no shortage of those either.

"raising the dead"

Rare. Elias, and then Elisaeus by his bones.

"calming the waters"

Where? Moses per Red Sea is at least not an exact parallel.

"because the inventor was creative."

I can totally relate to the idea of a defender now being involved in wishful thinking, but why would a creative inventor be there?

If people who had originally followed Jesus just for His doctrine without seeing a miracle were around after He suppposedly died but didn't rise, why would they suddenly start inventing miracle after miracle?

Paulogia hypothesises a kind of bottle-neck of one to three people (Peter, possibly John and James too) between the original followers of the living Jesus and the original believers in the Resurrection. Given what our sources say (and yes, they are mainly Christian) this is entirely unrealistic. If there had been such a discontinuity, why the TF? And no, "paradoxa erga" and "he was the Messiah" do not sound like Christian interpolations.





I think there is ONE very key flaw to all of the following:

one) in the early 1st Century among the apocalyptic preachers active in Judea was one Jesus of Nazareth
two) this Jesus said or did did controversial things which led to his crucifixion on a cross a common practice at the time
three) the resting place of Jesus's body was unknown to his followers
four) this Jesus had some followers while he was alive but most disappeared into lives never recorded by reliable history never to be heard from again all except Simon Peter and possibly John
five) distraught after the death of his mentor Simon Peter became sincerely albeit mistakenly convinced that Jesus had appeared to him
six) James the brother of Jesus became part of Peter's Jesus movement perhaps also one of the disciples named John
seven) stories about Jesus spread through person-to-person evangelism with the focus on recruiting new followers rather than accurately transmitting historical events details were embellished or invented to eliminate obstacles to belief and the narratives most successful at winning converts were repeated as the movement grew Peter was not personally present to confirm or correct the adopted narratives
eight) Paul a Pharisee who had been persecuting the new Christians out of a sincere belief that he was serving God experienced a non-veridical vision of the allegedly resurrected Jesus. Profoundly affected by this experience Paul became a Believer and began recruiting for Christianity and writing letters outlining his theology
nine) Paul met Peter and John but they didn't see eye to eye ten) several decades later Greek speaking individuals who had never met Jesus or Peter began documenting these circulating stories about Jesus the sayings attributed to him and their interpretations of these narratives
eleven) occasionally some early Christians engaged in disruptive behavior and faced consequences as a result however early Christians generally lived relatively peacefully rarely facing ideological persecution although it did occur at times they were accepting of others kind to the poor and widows and consequently grew in numbers
twelve) centuries later in 303 ad Christianity was temporarily outlawed in Rome but it gained legal protection 10 years later and soon became the Roman Empire's first official religion marking its transformation toward the institution we know today


Because the poor benighted Hebrews were incompetent at organisation, and because it's so easy for people who were in the Jesus Freaks (of the 1960's and 1970's) to retroactively describe their organisation like it reads like the Anglican Church with a Lambeth Conference?

I think people who retroactively describe their experience as highly organised were not living something highly disorganised. I mean collective experience.

The difference this makes is a difference between lecturing and a game of telephone.



1:05 Bart Ehrman has by those words:

  • outed himself as a loyal Humean
  • disqualified himself as a Historian (except to fellow Humeans).


He also is, like any Humean, confusing prior probability in expectation of the event and subsequent probability in assessing whether it happened.

Confer the two statements:

"I feel I'm going to win a million on Lotto" (very improbably)
"so and so won a million on Lotto" (entirely reasonable)

3:58 "treason" ... 1) would that have been applicable to a non-Roman? 2) aren't you assuming a fairly uniform legal practise of Romans as regards non-Roman Provincials, which might not have existed?

underachiever
@AgnosticApologist
Sedition or blasphemy, depending on who you ask. The sense of the word 'treason' is close enough for government work.

“We have no king but Caesar.” (John 19:15)
“You have heard the blasphemy. What is your decision?” And they all condemned him as deserving death. (Mark 14:64)

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@AgnosticApologist I would say, sedition was clearly not applicable, as Jesus didn't carry arms against Romans and told Pilate "my kingdom is not of this world" ... should have been good enough.

underachiever
@ My bottom line is that they saw him as a threat to Roman authorities, and so they charged him with whatever in order to stop him. What those exact charges were seem irrelevant to me when the context is already clear. He was an ideological threat. If your argument is more historically nuanced I’ll have to defer.

@ I’ll also add that the problematic nature of translation when it comes to precision in semantics muddies the waters significantly.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@ Would you mind to nuance the pronoun here:

"they saw him as a threat to Roman authorities"

Who "they"?

If you mean "the Jews" (i e Jewish enemies of Jesus, like St. John as narrator uses the word), who of themselves could not crucify anyone, they preferred viewing him as a blasphemer, which would have meant nothing to Pilate.

If you mean Pilate, why would we presume he was duped, when the Gospel account says the opposite?

underachiever
@hglundahl No thank you. We're getting overly bogged down in semantics.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@AgnosticApologist I think it really does matter.

Romans knew the difference between sedition and preaching (and they had no claims to doctrinal authority, so didn't see preaching as a threat), so, we would not expect Pilate to simply make a mistake.

We have no Jewish sources saying Jesus committed sedition against the Romans. Jewish sources that might refer to Jesus place Him (if so) in pre-Roman times.

We have only late and dismissive Roman voices about sedition.

We have the Christian voice for a very different scenario.

Now, if He had been a seditioner, there might have been some merit to the idea of His followers being heavily underorganised and therefore unable to check rumour mills among them. But if He was instead a teacher, who had students, these students were capable of organising the transmission of events, just as He had transmitted His idea of the Law.

underachiever
@hglundahl My emphasis is on ideological threat. The Romans might have distinguished between sedition and preaching, but the political climate of the time, much like now, might have led them to view Jesus' actions as subversive ('woke') even if they were not overtly seditious. Jesus was not simply a preacher in the traditional sense; his message about the coming Kingdom of God, his claim to authority, and his association with the idea of a new kingdom could have been seen as a direct challenge to Roman rule. Even without formal sedition, the Romans might have perceived his movement as destabilizing.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@AgnosticApologist Romans didn't care tuppence about woke versus based.

Roman élite tended to be 1/3 woke and 2/3 based, but they were based enough to consider Provincials being different from them [as] being easier to dominate.

"his message about the coming Kingdom of God, his claim to authority, and his association with the idea of a new kingdom could have been seen as a direct challenge to Roman rule"

We have no direct indication these exact words had come to Pilate's ears.

If anything, it was His insisting (twice over) that the fore-court of the Gentiles should serve as such, and Pilate might get worried the Centurions could go soft if they were not crowded out of that court by merchants and sacrificial animals and money-changers.

Even if this were so, at least this allows for fully respecting the indication that Jesus per se was a teacher and able to organise teaching, and therefore the Church surviving Him would not have been one highly disorganised rumour-mill. Paulogia's scenario basically presupposes it's worse than the South Korean internet.


4:51 "a notion nearly as impossible as a resurrection"

1) Not if the condemnation was made unwillingly, as we read of Pilate.
2) Not if someone who was influential petitioned.

Confer a bit Navalny ... Putin had reasons to not allow him out of things alive, but he somehow didn't feel up to banning a very honourable funeral. True, in this case, Russia had fairly uniform laws about burials, so condemned criminals (Navalny's legal status, I'd say an undeserved one) can be buried openly and solemnly.

5:12 "arising centuries later"

According to Protestant critics of the papacy, for instance.

The safest bet with a tradition in general is, it goes back to the event.

The second safest bet is, you have some stronger evidence about the event, and you have some pretty good scenario about why the tradition came to include an error.

(Manuscript tradition of LXX where Methuselah begets at 167 rather than 187, a) it's contrary to Samaritan and Masoretic — not the worst — b) it involves Methuselah dying after the Flood, c) the previous verse or the one before that involves the numeral sixty more than once).




[Quoting larger chunks from transscript in the following]

"stories about Jesus spread 7:21 through person-to-person evangelism with 7:24 the focus on recruiting new followers 7:26 rather than accurately transmitting 7:28 historical events"


Totally reconstructed, no way near any tradition about how the tradition actually spread.

I mean speeches before mass audiences are more like it.

"as the movement grew Peter was 7:40 not personally present to confirm or 7:42 correct the adopted narratives"


He was personally present in places like Antioch and Rome to as late as under Nero.

Michael Newsham
@michaelnewsham1412
Ah, another believer of the accepted traditions of the Angel Moroni and the Golden Tablets. Or is it the tradition of the Archangel Gabriel dictating the Quran?

@hglundahl "I know, for the Bible tells me so", to coin a phrase.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@hglundahl
@michaelnewsham1412 I believe Joseph Smith absolutely had to trust the "angel Moroni" whom no one else saw, because the Mormon tradition tells me so.

I believe Mohammed absolutely had to trust his Djibreel, who also no one else so. Because the Muslim tradition tells me so.

So, I believe that the guys seeing Jesus risen were several and his bodily presence was ascertained by St. Thomas and by His serving fish breakfast. Because the Catholic tradition tells me so.

In each case the tradition goes back to the original witnesses to something, I just think one of the "witness setups" is clearly superior to the other two.





"the Jesus 7:45 movement grew for many decades before 7:47 the first gospels were written so 7:49 Scholars generally agree that it spread 7:51 primarily through personal evangelism 7:54 and Word of Mouth rather than through 7:56 written texts or formal institutions"


As those formal institutions would be Catholic ones, this is the self serving reconstruction by Protestants (not primarily Evangelicals).


St. Matthew, the author of the gospel that we have under his name, was a Galilean, the son of Alpheus, a Jew, and a tax-gatherer; he was known also by the name of Levi. His vocation happened in the second year of the public ministry of Christ; who, soon after forming the college of his apostles, adopted him into that holy family of the spiritual princes and founders of his Church. Before his departure from Judea, to preach the gospel to distant countries, he yielded to the solicitations of the faithful; and about the eighth year after our Saviour's resurrection, the forty-first of the vulgar era [A.D. 41], he began to write his gospel: i.e., the good tidings of salvation to man, through Christ Jesus, our Lord.



See Butler's Saints' Lives, September 21st

The intro to Mark has no date given.


[St. Luke's] gospel, therefore, he wrote as he heard it; but the Acts of the Apostles, from his own observations; and both, as some believe, about the same time in which his history of the Acts finishes, towards the year of Christ 63. But the received opinion now is, that St. Luke wrote his gospel in Achaia, in the year 53, ten years previously to his writing of the Acts, purposely to counteract the fabulous relations concerning Jesus Christ, which several persons had endeavoured to palm upon the world.



ON the fourth Gospel, we agree it was late ...

"10 several decades later 9:36 Greek speaking individuals who had never 9:38 met Jesus or Peter began documenting 9:41 these circulating stories about Jesus 9:43 the sayings attributed to him and their 9:45 interpretations of these narratives"


Pretty much the wishful thinking of Tovia Singer.

" the 9:48 case against the traditional authorship 9:50 of the gospels is strong"


Not really.

"(12) centuries later in 303 ad 11:41 Christianity was temporarily outlawed in 11:44 Rome but it gained legal protection 10 11:47 years later and soon became the Roman 11:49 Empire's first official religion marking 11:51 its transformation toward the 11:53 institution we know today"


Actually, Christians were persecuted far longer than that, after Nero, who's using Senatus Consultum de Bacchanalibus as precedent, Pliny the Younger consults on what to do with people staunchly refusing to sacrifice to idols.

While these people are not directly guarantors of the Resurrection accounts, they are guarantors of having received them in what was to them a credible form (like eyewitnesses known and known to be martyred, like written texts, like an Institution known as the Catholic Church).

The idea the latter was basically a by-product of Constantine is the wishful thinking of Hislop ... (a Protestant who definitely hated Catholicism).

Wednesday, March 12, 2025

OT Violence is NOT Going Away from Debates, and We Are NOT Allowed to Say God Didn't Order It


OT Violence is NOT Going Away from Debates, and We Are NOT Allowed to Say God Didn't Order It · Innate Flaw in Jericho

Randal Rauser certainly has a bias, like we can see from other videos of his. One has the title "Why the Devil Loves Christian Fundamentalists", and one has the title "Frank Turek's Apologetics is Worse than You Imagined", the latter being a follow up to the one linked to below. The standpoint in the latter basically comes down to "you may do Apologetics in long books" (Randal Rauser has written one) "but you have no right to do quick apologetics on the spot, in a context of back-and-forth." I'll also comment on two points he made in it, and link to it.


How Not to Answer an Atheist's Question about God and the Bible
Randal Rauser - The Tentative Apologist | 12 mars 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6XVFDYjpS0


4:55 Apologist and missionary aren't the same thing.

St. Thomas says, with some people we argue, not to convert them, because in such cases we may have reasons we can't, only a miracle of God can, meaning a major one, but in order to convert and defend from apostasy, whoever is listening.

5:17 Given my experience of Turek, this is not true.*

Turek STARTS with the question why the atheist is expecting either mercy or consistency.

But he usually goes ON TO give an actual explanation of how the killing of Jerichoites was consistent with God's mercy. Here is how I would do it, and I don't think Turek would disagree very much.

A first step is to accept, unlike us, God as author of life and death, and as knowing us intimately, has a right to determine when anyone dies.

Are not two sparrows sold for a farthing? and not one of them shall fall on the ground without your Father.
[Matthew 10:29]

Second, God as author of morality can make men executioners of a sentence which, without express divine order would be immoral. ANOTHER example is how Samson (on a prompting by the Holy Spirit) kills himself while killing Philistines. Normally killing oneself is totally illicit. But in this case, God wanted the Philistines dead, for the deliverance of Israel, and He wanted Samson freed from the disastrous love he had held for Delilah, and He took these things into account to authorise and even order Samson to do this.

Third, obviously, why did such and such deserve to die?

Jericho had basically stood since the days of Nimrod, and its haughtiness would have blocked Israelites from taking into possession a land that God had meant for them, and ultimately for Jesus. This includes the re-united Israelites (Judah and Ephraim reunited) known as Palestinians. So, without a place to worship, how would Israelites have learned the ways of God? Continuing in the desert not just would have taken miracle after miracle, but had already exasperated them. Meanwhile, Jerichoites other than the harlot Rahab were not a realistic target for God's or anyone's missionary efforts. They could not join Israel. They could not become adopted Israelites. This was no longer the case with Gabaon, as we read in Joshua 9.

Frank Turek's Apologetics is Worse than You Imagined
Randal Rauser - The Tentative Apologist | 12 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-AmWFZ1pxg


7:57 "We are not talking of people here dying of natural causes."

God is ending every life that ends. Whether the cause be natural or Joshua or Ted Bundy. Or a Fraternity during Hell week.

You can be God's tool for this by negligence (if you drive uncautiously), by culpable ill-will, or, as God's executioner. Joshua did God's executioner. Not executioner for essentially human justice according to God's law, but as executioner of a sentence God made. God has as much right to send Jerichoites and Hai-ites a violence without justice, as He has to get an adulterous woman NOT stoned in John 8, despite the Torahic sentence. In John 8, the Old Covenant was still in function, except Israelites has lost the sovereignty. So, if the woman was culpable, she should normally have been stoned. This mercy goes beyond human justice as it was applicable at this point. And so did the mercy killing of babies who were spared being raised by Jerichoites, a thousand times worse than what some now see as a horror, being raised by Islamists.

Note, God killed them, He didn't tell the Israelites to kill their parents and then raise them. If all the parents and older siblings had been killed but pre-puber children would have been spared, they would have died anyway, for lack of sustenance, or been killed or enslaved by other people. And the point is, it is one against CPS, God preferred Israel killing children too over Israel raising Jerichoites whom they had killed the parents of.

10:48 Dena Schlosser was not divinely authorised by a God who worked miracles.

And the actual story doesn't seem to be she tried to kill her baby, but she tried to amputate her arms, and death ensued.

And I think God was merciful when not allowing Margaret Schlosser to grow up under Dena Schlosser.

Please note, Dena's life had already been pretty ruined by years of anti-psychotic drugs.

The things done to Dena since her crime have not shown that psychiatry is a lifesaver. In and out, in and out of psychiatry. Her life is destroyed. Had she been sentenced to death or given years of prison, she might be happier than as it is now. I believe even criminals should some time have the right to happiness, in some cases like last meal and reconciliation with God before execution. For the criminal Dena, but for lots of others who are not criminals, psychiatry is ruining that.**

* Whatever Turek video Randal Rauser was showing, the clip was very short, and then it was interrupted when Turek said "secondly, I would ask the question" ...

** It would amount to religious persecution if it considered someone as psychotic for essentially agreeing theologically with Turek. As Swedish psychiatry did with my mother.

She Put the Tattoo to Good Use


Why I regret this tattoo
Taylor Alesia | 13 Sept. 2024
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r1Gpffa5jJ4


October 13th? Actually one female saint on that day:

13 Octobris
Sancti Eduardi, Regis Anglorum et Confessoris, qui Nonis Januarii obdormivit in Domino, sed hac die, ob Translationem corporis ejus, potissimum colitur.

Apud Troadem, Asiae minoris urbem, natalis sancti Carpi, qui fuit discipulus beati Pauli Apostoli.

Cordubae, in Hispania, item natalis sanctorum Martyrum Fausti, Januarii et Martialis; qui, primo equulei poena cruciati, deinde, superciliis rasis, dentibus evulsis, auribus quoque et naribus praecisis, ignis passione martyrium consummarunt.

Thessalonicae sancti Florentii Martyris, qui, post varia tormenta, igne combustus est.

Apud Stokeraviam, in Austria, sancti Colmanni Martyris.

Antiochiae sancti Theophili Episcopi, qui, sextus post beatum Petrum Apostolum, ejusdem Ecclesiae Pontificatum tenuit.

Turonis, in Gallia, sancti Venantii, Abbatis et Confessoris.

Apud Sublacum, in Latio, sanctae Chelidoniae Virginis.

Et alibi aliorum plurimorum sanctorum Martyrum et Confessorum, atque sanctarum Virginum. R. Deo gratias.


The Dominical letter is an A, so, you are born a year when January 1st was also a Lord's Day.*

2:53 Not just the artist.

St. Paul in Romans 1 is speaking about things that were visible from creation which prove certain things of God, one of which is inexhaustible power.**

Well, if Earth stands still and if each day the rest of the visible universe turns around us, something or someone turning it around would need inexhaustible power. And if it were some thing rather than some one the intricacy of Geocentric astronomy wouldn't work.

I often say "God turns the Zodiac around us each day, in 23 hours 55 minutes, an angel turns the Sun around the Zodiac in one year" ... I am not implying any destiny in where the Sun goes, I'm simply saying "zodiac" instead of "ecliptic plane" because it's a more well known concept.

3:09 Lest perhaps lifting up thy eyes to heaven, thou see the sun and the moon, and all the stars of heaven, and being deceived by error thou adore and serve them, which the Lord thy God created for the service of all the nations, that are under heaven [Deuteronomy 4:19]

Obviously, if you believe a spirit is taking the Sun around empty space around the Earth from East to West, you might be tempted to worship that spirit instead of God who is turning all of them from East to West, while each is taking its own heavenly body (Sun, Moon, planets, a bit different for fix stars) around the Zodiac in a much slower pace from West to East.

3:53 It's not just about the Creator for those who have access to Genesis 1:1.

It's about the Mover of Heaven, which was accessible as an argument for Aristotle.

Now, some have recently stated (since Karl Marx's dissertation, actually, before he apostatised) that St. Paul in Colossians 2:8 targetted Aristotle whose philosophy involve "the four elements" but did you know that an alternative name for the "atoms" of Democritus and Epicurus and Lucretius was "elements"?

St. Paul in Colossians is lambasting Epicure, and in Romans 1 upholding Aristotle as a philosopher, while condemning him as a person (he actually did offer sacrifice to pagan gods and not to the prime mover he could prove).

7:10 "invite Him into your heart"

Between the Francis of Sales and Theodore Beza, successor of Calvin, two persons claiming the allegiance of Genevans (the bishop set his foot in that city twice or so, and he failed to access Beza on his deathbed) ... who of the two said so, over and over?

Beza's words are accessible in a Geneva Bible, which is commented.***

the theology of Calvin, Luther, Zwingli, and other Reformation leaders. It was first printed in 1560. / on the site Study Light (Beza edited it)


Francis of Sales' words are accessible in Introduction to the Devout Life, TAN Books.

By the way, I did so at age 10 (I'm 56).

Can GOD be known with CERTAINTY? Yes! Discovering the Catechism Episode 5
Catholic Unscripted | 12.III.2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bjrx0o_pF8M


9:46 Omnipotent isn't problematic at all, provided you start with Prima Via and, as Riccioli says (though for another reason he doesn't accept it) considers this as a proof from God's daily moving of the universe around us, that is, from Geocentrism.

Unless you for some inscrutable reason, or by sheer inconsistency (in any non-atheist, or anyone not a rabid atheist) start out by ruling out Geocentrism.

Even if Sirius is only one light-day up it would be seriously (!) impossible for anything less than omnipotence to move it full circle day after day around us.

OK, to Riccioli, the angel of Sirius was himself taking Sirius around earth. However, Riccioli's empty space for heaven is not an option after Foucault's pendulum. Either there is a common movement in all space surrounding Earth up to Sirius, and then the angel of Sirius can't be what's moving that, but someone bigger has to be that, or Earth would need to move around its axis, which we have no obvious reason to believe.

10:13 The relation of omnipotent, omniscient and our freewill is not the least problematic.

While God's omnipotence certainly would be sufficient to crush any free will He wanted to crush, that's not how God usually uses His omnipotence.

Given how God knows things, as St. Boethius said well before Aquinas, God's knowledge doesn't work in a way that limits free causalities (such as human freewill) in what He knows.

10:38 " 'proof' isn't accurate" ...

I hear a very dissonant echo from Ratzinger. This issue, and how he pretended "as per Einstein, Geocentrism is equally accurate" were the first warning signals about this man.

While the Church doesn't "offer a proof" (as in specify which proof) this doesn't mean we could say there is no actual proof.

Two kinds of things can be known with certainty. Things that are immediately evident, like a leaf being green, or being not being non-being (in the same aspect), and, things that are proven from such as are evident. Romans 1 places the existence and omnipotence of God into the latter category.

And Romans 1 also places the evidence material for that proof, or the main evidence material, within what could be observed with the naked eye all the 5200 + years from God creating Adam to when St. Paul was speaking. Geocentrism fits the bill.

10:47 If you can get to a point where you cannot doubt this, is this a subjective fact about your situation, or if not perfectly subjective at least sth which you could have a hard time communicating? Sth which C. S. Lewis could communicate in Surprised by Joy? But then CSL is CSL, and a genius of communication ...

Or is it a hard objective impossibility to doubt (unless you have bad faith)? One that can be fairly easily communicated.

In the latter case, it is actual proof. It can be formulated as actual proof.

And if there are since then red herrings, like the idea of Earth turning around her axis, they can be shown to be red herrings.

11:13 Catholic Heliocentrics, i e inconsistent people, have a knack of taking the proof by St. Thomas to be Tertia Via.

However, he himself said the most obvious one was Prima Via.

Manifestum est et patet sensibus aliquid moveri, utputa sol ...


11:47 In Tertia via, Aquinas is not yet dealing with the qualities of esse.

He is not yet determining whether it's one, whether it's good or whether it has any kind of consciousness at all. Here is the actual text of Tertia via, in Prima Pars, Q 2 A 3:

The third way is taken from possibility and necessity, and runs thus. We find in nature things that are possible to be and not to be, since they are found to be generated, and to corrupt, and consequently, they are possible to be and not to be. But it is impossible for these always to exist, for that which is possible not to be at some time is not. Therefore, if everything is possible not to be, then at one time there could have been nothing in existence. Now if this were true, even now there would be nothing in existence, because that which does not exist only begins to exist by something already existing. Therefore, if at one time nothing was in existence, it would have been impossible for anything to have begun to exist; and thus even now nothing would be in existence — which is absurd. Therefore, not all beings are merely possible, but there must exist something the existence of which is necessary. But every necessary thing either has its necessity caused by another, or not. Now it is impossible to go on to infinity in necessary things which have their necessity caused by another, as has been already proved in regard to efficient causes. Therefore we cannot but postulate the existence of some being having of itself its own necessity, and not receiving it from another, but rather causing in others their necessity. This all men speak of as God.


Necessity and eternity of being are however already given in tertia via.

12:29 "you come to recognise"

Those words are nowhere in the corpus of Q 2 A 3. Before the text of the five ways, you have this intro:

I answer that, The existence of God can be proved in five ways.


14:04 Humani Generis § 2

2. It is not surprising that such discord and error should always have existed outside the fold of Christ. For though, absolutely speaking, human reason by its own natural force and light can arrive at a true and certain knowledge of the one personal God, Who by His providence watches over and governs the world, and also of the natural law, which the Creator has written in our hearts, still there are not a few obstacles to prevent reason from making efficient and fruitful use of its natural ability. The truths that have to do with God and the relations between God and men, completely surpass the sensible order and demand self-surrender and self-abnegation in order to be put into practice and to influence practical life. Now the human intellect, in gaining the knowledge of such truths is hampered both by the activity of the senses and the imagination, and by evil passions arising from original sin. Hence men easily persuade themselves in such matters that what they do not wish to believe is false or at least doubtful.


Here the footnote goes to Vatican I, On Revelation, where the first 4 points are:

1) The same holy mother church holds and teaches that God, the source and end of all things,
can be known
with certainty from the consideration of created things,
by the natural power of human reason : ever since the creation of the world, his invisible nature has been clearly perceived in the things that have been made. [13]

2) It was, however, pleasing to his wisdom and goodness to reveal
himself and
the eternal laws of his will
to the human race by another, and that a supernatural, way.

This is how the Apostle puts it : In many and various ways God spoke of old to our fathers by the prophets; but in these last days he has spoken to us by a Son [14] .

3) It is indeed thanks to this divine revelation, that those matters concerning God
which are not of themselves beyond the scope of human reason,
can, even in the present state of the human race, be known
by everyone°
without difficulty,
with firm certitude and
with no intermingling of error.

4) It is not because of this that one must hold revelation to be absolutely necessary; the reason is that God directed human beings to a supernatural end, that is a sharing in the good things of God that utterly surpasses the understanding of the human mind; indeed eye has not seen, neither has ear heard, nor has it come into our hearts to conceive what things God has prepared for those who love him [15] .


Now, the council of 1870 did NOT put stating that all of the truths about God, specifically His omnipotence, are hampered by the activity of the senses, the truths about God that are so hampered are the ones which call for our adhesion to an end above nature.

14:39 The true God becomes inaccessible as much to the Muslim who has a disordered appetite for spotting and punishing sodomy and drunkenness even where these things are not obviously apparent, as to a Woke-Commie, whose disordered appetite for sexual experience with no consequence in children to take care of leads him to conclude for "no God" where the Muslim has a false "God" (if it were true that "if a big quantity intoxicates, even a little quantity is haram" then one could not eat, because eating in certain quantities actually is intoxicating ... the real God cannot put such nonsense in His real revelation).

15:06 "no, we don't consider these things"

OK, is it still hidden if:

  • a promise of old age pensions
  • easy access to contraceptives and somewhat more difficult but not prohibitive to abortion
  • lead to an aging of society
  • which leads to hollowing out of resources for old age pensions
  • and to loneliness of the old, and to annoyance among the young who are surrounded by old eager to advice them as much as old ones are surrounded by young ones eager to get advice on some point in saner societies
  • and to Putin needing to do shenanigans in order to keep Navalny from pushing him down
  • up to when the Covid epidemic and later the special operation continued to take attention from the issue where in 2019 he actually failed.


Similar things can be said about Macron.

22:08 "we are all children before God"

But not before each other.

Cain obviously thought he as big brother was a mature adult before God, but little brother Abel was somehow unable to take his own decisions. He didn't like being told at the sacrifice that he was not his brother's actual keeper.

23:33 In some items brought about during WW-II, Nazis were doing a bad echo of the English camps in South Africa during the Boer war.

But as to peacetime, it's not obvious that Nazis were worse baddies than Social Democrats since then, notably in Sweden, or Progressive Democrats in Canada, where I think Eugenics was abolished in the 1970's as in Scandinavia, and where Euthanasia by far surpasses the T-4 programme, evil as it was.

According°° to a writing by Reichsführer-SS Heinrich Himmler, the Totenkopf had the following meaning: The Skull is the reminder that you shall always be willing to put your self at stake for the life of the whole community.


So, the Skull as such is not exactly an insignium of evil intent. Nor were all who wore it evil. It's pretty obvious Otto Carius or Colonel Valentin Müller were good people, but they are insofar bad examples about the Skull as they were Wehrmacht, not SS.

24:54 "and no admixture of error"

A good reason to reject a Catechism which actually does admix error in § 283.

25:19 Quibble, I think you mistook Incas for Aztecs.

Incas had human sacrifice too, but not hundreds of thousands.

27:00 Katherine Bennett ... you might enjoy the chapters I already wrote of Chronicle of Susan Pevensie.

The relation between Lucy and Susan, prior to and after the train wreck that kills Lucy, is described a bit in terms of Psyche and Orual.




* Actually not true. In October, 1, 8, 15, 22, 29 are A. I trusted the martyrology online, but after October 2nd correctly marked as B, October 3rd was incorrectly marked as E instead of C. Vandalism? Will it be fixed?

** The motor in the virus from CMI's article tomorrow (except it's already March 13th in Australia) is proof against abiogenesis, to be sure, but this is accessed only by microscopes that weren't available in St. Paul's day. It's a complement to what he was talking about, but it's not the main item.

*** I look up.

Behold, I stand at the gate, and knock. If any man shall hear my voice, and open to me the door, I will come in to him, and will sup with him, and he with me.
[Apocalypse (Revelation) 3:20]

Catholic theologians galore: "Jesus is knocking on the door of your heart, open up, quickly!"

Beza / Geneva Bible:

3:20 Behold, I stand at the door, and knock: {14} if any man hear my voice, and open the door, I will come in to him, and will sup with him, and he with me.

(14) This must be taken after the manner of an allegory; John 14:23


° "by everyone" ... St. Thomas and Pius IX are not speaking about a boy in Tibet who grows up believing he's a reincarnation of some Boddhisattva, but "everyone" means "all sorts of people" namely the cleaning lady as much as the professor, the sinner as much as the virtuous philosopher.

°° https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Totenkopf

Once Upon a Time, KGB Compared Christian Fundamentalists to Jihadists and Shariah Upholders. Kirill did so early on as Patriarch. He was obviously, like Putin, a KGB man, up to November 1991


Fact Checking The BIble. Do Christians Fact Check The New Testament? Is The Bible A Lie?
DEBUNKING CHRISTIAN FUNDAMENTALISM | 9 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XCeEGUVaaRg


4:03 No, I wasn't.

The only thing I got at three is, God created everything.

Ma was not allowed to raise me after her conscience until later. At an age when I could ask critical questions. It took me about a year to give up attempts to harmonise evolution as I had believed it since age six, with the Bible.

But while I could ask critical questions, try to look for other possibilities and so, I was still a very young Fundamentalist, a pre-teen.

You believe you have everyone's story at your fingertips, just because you have your own. Not true. I've spent much of the years from 2001 to the present on the internet fact checking Christian claims versus claims from your side. By now, I actually very well have fact checked what you are asking for.

4:10 "no different from how the young Muslim Juihadist was brainwashed"

Jihadists in general, and including young ones need more than just the Muslim version of Fundamentalism to go on Jihad. Like people of YOUR type (or taking THEIR action bec. of what your type says) walking over their personal or family lives simply for them being Fundamentalists, or in the case of many Gazawis and West-Bankian Palestinians, for living on land that a settler wants.

Coulibaly was being a ticket out of France for his wife who was since her youth harrassed by French CPS. The Nice truck driver (no, not nice, but Nice, a k a Nizza) had personally been harrassed by psychiatry, which was also the case with a man who stabbed a policewoman and got shot in the process. Merah was actually a clear Islamist, but not from childhood. He also came from an extremely dysfunctional family and situation.

4:48 I'm sorry, but you are wildly guessing about the family background of people who simply are Fundamentalists or were raised such by their parents.

You are also to a high degree twisting criteria.

If school and parents disagree, normally, it's parents who could complain of school brainwashing, not the other way round.

5:07 "all the genres of science are wrong"

Wild parody.

ICR, AiG and CMI would be validating more mainstream science than I do, insofar as they are Heliocentrics. I'm Geocentric. We all believe biology as a study of contemporary facts. We all believe electronics or electromagnetism, mechanics, optics, acoustics, Mendel's laws of heredity, biogenesis, tensions in liquid's surfaces and so on. We all believe an object freely falling from normal habitable height will be accelerating at a rate of roughly 1 m per sq sec. Like after one second, it's one meter down, after two seconds, four meter, after three seconds, nine meter ... or that Hydrogen has one valence, Oxygen two, Nitrogen three, Carbon four. And double bonds imply both atoms on the sides of it have at least two valences.

Only very few genres of science, and in these only some of the schools and these not the most ancient ones,actually involved any conflict with the Bible and so with truth.

You don't go to Geology to find out if the Bible is true, you may go to the Bible to find out whether a certain type of Geology (not that of Steno) is true. Obviously provided you are a Christian.

You obviously aren't. You are fine with Christian imagination as psychological support, and with Christian values because Dialectic Materialism doesn't provide any values. But your actual own religious truth claim is for a kind of metaphysics and its application in sciences that's basically Dia-Mat. You probably even believe in Abiogenesis.

5:20 "you'll find there is no scientific method in their research"

Well, not if by "scientific method" you mean adherence to Dia-Mat and excluding God and angels and miracles as possible causes of anything that's actually verifiable.

You are outing yourself rather than the guys you attack.

5:37 You are switching the roles.

ICR, AiG, CMI are repeatedly adressing mainstream scientists who push Old Earth or Galaxies Billions of years old (remember, I believe both are wrong, CMI is wrong for believing Heliocentrism and pureley gravitational factors).

Mainstream scientists are on the other hand usually depending on being mainstream and prefer to marginalise ICR, AiG, CMI. Over actually interacting.

7:05 There was very certainly no global enslavement of Hebrews under Ramses ... except possibly in Canaan. Ramses I and II both fall in the judges period. Part of that time, Hebrews were under Canaanite tyranny.

The cities of tabernacles, Pithom and Ramesses can very well have the second of them named for a Ramses, but that's because Scribes in the Tabernacle were allowed to update place names. Not because the Exodus belongs in the Ramses period of Egyptian history.

Look for the evidence in the WRONG period, and you are certain to not find it, because you are not looking in the right period.

7:43 Thank you very much for showing how a Christian should support the LXX.

Btw, the oldest complete Masoretic text is way younger than the LXX.

7:58 I have come across this statement from your type of anti-Christian Apologetics.

"When Paul said there were 500 witnesses, he was bluffing, he knew his audience had no possibility to travel to check"


Well, that's presuming a very Capitalistic society with very big and efficient businesses and nearly nothing besides, no house slaves, and no men with leasure, and obviously, only proletarian people listening, who wouldn't be allowed to get away.

Arguably, a slave who wouldn't be allowed to get away to Jerusalem to check 500 witnesses would[n't] be allowed to get away to hearing St. Paul even a second time. The first time could be because the master had no idea who was there. The first Christians DID involve lots of upper class people as well. Like Philemon, a slave owner. Or Middle Class, liberal propfessions, like St. Luke, physician to St. Paul.

8:53 You have the place of the empty tomb preserved by tradition from when it happened to when Constantine was Emperor, and his mother St. Helen did her archaeo-archaeology in the Holy Land.

9:00 "you must understand that you have been programmed" because it wasn't Charles Hurst, now Apostate, who did the programming.

Scientists did NOT just find new evidence of Noah’s Ark
Dan McClellan | 11 March 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJ49EKCcUkc


Did you say one of those collaborating was an Adventist University?

As my dad once upon a time was a 7DA (no longer the case) and as I somewhat carelessly said so in a letter to some 7DA (which might make them think I was raised 7DA, but my dad didn't raise me), and as I'm well known to be Catholic while they have their take on who the Antichrist is (rather "what" than "who" since they find 1260 days to be "prophetic days and literal years" and the Pope hasn't been the same man all this time), this could partially explain the black-out about my work. While CMI are competent, except in ecclesiology (or they wouldn't be Protestants) and some related, they are also getting some sponsoring from the 7DA, I seem to recall.

1:27 He is more like arguing that formation was actually submerged during the Flood.

My best evidence for Noah's Ark resting in the mountainS of "Ararat" (Urartu, Armenia) and Babel coming after that, is, Genesis 11:2.

And when they removed from the east, they found a plain in the land of Sennaar, and dwelt in it
[Genesis 11:2]

Posit Sennaar = Mesopotamia.

Mount Judi is just east of the Tigris, so, to get into Mesopotamia from Mount Judi, you need to literally remove "from the East" (if you go the closest way).

300 + km from there, further west, so, still "removing from the East" you find Göbekli Tepe. It's on the northern edge of a pretty squareish plain that is inside Mesopotamia. Göbekli Tepe is also inside Mesopotamia, both official courses of Euphrates and of Tigris start further North.

I say "official course", because I'm not counting from water sheds where water runs the other way on the other side, but I'm counting where smaller rivers meet and officially the confluency product is called Fırat (Euphrates) and Dicle (Tigris) as it flows South-ish, but none of the confluent rivers bears that name further North.

And before you go off a tangent to say that Babel is the same name as the city of Nebuchadnezzar, well Boston (MA) is the same name as Boston (UK) too, and there is tablet evidence that Sargon of Akkad did something to Babilu. There are more than one way to interpret it, but the one that best suits my case is, he destroyed a Babel somewhere in what's now Eastern Turkey and refounded Babilu as the city formerly known as Akkad / Agade. Which would explain why no archaeologist ever found Agade. They were looking outside Classic Babylon instead of under it. At least as far as the naming is concerned.

The tablet known as ABC 20 “The Chronicle of Early Kings”32 relates Sargon’s last campaign of conquest to Subartu as follows:

“Afterwards, Subartu attacked Sargon in full
force and called him to arms.
Sargon set an ambush and completely defeated them.
He overpowered their extensive army
and sent their possessions into Akkad.
He dug up the dirt of the pit of Babylon and
made a counterpart of Babylon next to Agade.”


Ken Griffith and Darrell K. White, "An Upper Mesopotamian location for Babel" JOURNAL OF CREATION 35(2) 2021 [Also quoted on my blog post Ah, Griffith and White Provided the Source Too]

2:02 The evidence for human presence 5500 to 3000 BC would probably be carbon dates.

That being so, they would be another evidence against this being the real site.

Because, the real dates for these carbon dates would be:

2258 BC
66.981 pmC, dated as 5571 BC
2235 BC
68.129 pmC, dated as 5407 BC


(between birth of Serug and death of Peleg)

1779 BC
85.963 pmC, dated as 3029 BC


(after Ishmael died).

[tried to add]

pmC figures refer to original C 14 levels in the atmosphere back then, not remainder in the samples now