Tuesday, January 10, 2023

Some Creationists Cannot Get Contradicted on Detail By Me, Without Thinking I Contradict Creationism


Assorted retorts from yahoo boards and elsewhere: Some Creationists Cannot Get Contradicted on Detail By Me, Without Thinking I Contradict Creationism · Creation vs. Evolution: Mount Judi or Durupinar?

Weird, but that's how it is,
first the video, where I made a detail criticism very early on:


Noah's Ark: The New Evidence
Trey Smith | 3 Jan. 2023
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N-V0qGW2d6Y


and, next, my criticism for a specific timestamp and a brief exchange following it:

Hans-Georg Lundahl
2:27 It is actually c. 300 km from Mountains of Ararat (the most westernmost and a good candidate being Mt Judi) and Göbekli Tepe in the land of Shinar, just north of the Harran plain.

The journey Judi GT is removing from the east

HiTechOilCo
God does not lie. "and on the seventeenth day of the seventh month the ark came to rest on the mountains of Ararat" - Genesis 8:4, N.I.V.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@HiTechOilCo Yes, exactly.

OF ARARAT.

That is the mountain range of Armenia, and its Western limit is Mount Judi.

Hans-Georg Lundahl
@HiTechOilCo I rewatched. Bad sound first time.

Yes, Trey Smith considered Göbekli Tepe as "towards the mountains of Ararat" which is only true compared to where he is still placing the Tower of Babel (namely in Sumerian Eridu).

Göbekli Tepe is my candidate for the city of Babel.

It is legitimately in Shinar, if that means Mesopotamia, and it is right at the three quarters West mark of the Northern border of a fairly squareish plain and that plain is inside Mesopotamia, up there, not around it as at Eridu.

No comments: